
Essays
Essays
Examiner Report II
Examiner Report 1
Examiner Report II
Arts and The State
Arts and The State
Should the arts rely on government support?
Should the arts rely on government support?
Nov 12, 2026
Nov 12, 2026
(RI 2024 Prelims)
The arts should not rely on government support. What is your view?
The following content is only available to Deluxe subscribers.
Make an upgrade today.
Get Deluxe →
Deluxe
$18.60/m
A Step Above
All features within the Premium Track at your fingertips
Full access to all Essays.
Starter Kit — detailed cheat sheet to help you ace all components of the essay, released in stages.
Priority access to new services, including the Essay Studio.
Deluxe
A Step Above
$16.50/m $18.60
All features in the Premium Track.
Full access to all Essays.
Full Starter Kit — to help you ace all components of the essay, released in stages.
Priority access to new services, including the Essay Studio.
General Notes
General Notes
General Notes
On Examples
You do not have to use all the examples we offer for each paragraph; 2-3 well-developed ones are more than sufficient.
Feel free to replace the examples with your own, so long as you follow the correspondence rule, which basically means that your example needs to contain information which supports all parts of the argument you’re making.
For example: our first topic sentence is that the accessibility and development of art depends on governmental support, which provides both the publicity and financial backing.
Thus our example must address these points: 1) evidence of government support, 2) evidence that art has been made accessible, and 3) any evidence that this support contributes to the development of the arts
This will also be reiterated later on in the report!
On Examples
You do not have to use all the examples we offer for each paragraph; 2-3 well-developed ones are more than sufficient.
Feel free to replace the examples with your own, so long as you follow the correspondence rule, which basically means that your example needs to contain information which supports all parts of the argument you’re making.
For example: our first topic sentence is that the accessibility and development of art depends on governmental support, which provides both the publicity and financial backing.
Thus our example must address these points: 1) evidence of government support, 2) evidence that art has been made accessible, and 3) any evidence that this support contributes to the development of the arts
This will also be reiterated later on in the report!
On Examples
You do not have to use all the examples we offer for each paragraph; 2-3 well-developed ones are more than sufficient.
Feel free to replace the examples with your own, so long as you follow the correspondence rule, which basically means that your example needs to contain information which supports all parts of the argument you’re making.
For example: our first topic sentence is that the accessibility and development of art depends on governmental support, which provides both the publicity and financial backing.
Thus our example must address these points: 1) evidence of government support, 2) evidence that art has been made accessible, and 3) any evidence that this support contributes to the development of the arts
This will also be reiterated later on in the report!
II. How You can Practice Using This Report
Reading through this page is going to be decently helpful, but you stand to gain so much more. Here's the mental exercise we recommend if you want to practice thinking yourself before we reveal the answers; we'll also use Antithesis 1 as a worked example.
Mental Exercise For Each Body Paragraph / Thesis
In the style of a rocket launch
II. How You can Practice Using This Report
Reading through this page is going to be decently helpful, but you stand to gain so much more. Here's the mental exercise we recommend if you want to practice thinking yourself before we reveal the answers; we'll also use Antithesis 1 as a worked example.
Mental Exercise For Each Body Paragraph / Thesis
In the style of a rocket launch
II. How You can Practice Using This Report
Reading through this page is going to be decently helpful, but you stand to gain so much more. Here's the mental exercise we recommend if you want to practice thinking yourself before we reveal the answers; we'll also use Antithesis 1 as a worked example.
Mental Exercise For Each Body Paragraph / Thesis
In the style of a rocket launch
T - 4
T - 4
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
The most common ones are 1) appearance vs reality, 2) paradox, 3) irony, and 4) layering — often, these are sufficient for most essays you’ll ever encounter.
Why these frameworks, you may ask? That’s because any one of them will definitely give you more to talk about in your evaluation and accompanying explanation/elaborations.
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
The most common ones are 1) appearance vs reality, 2) paradox, 3) irony, and 4) layering — often, these are sufficient for most essays you’ll ever encounter.
Why these frameworks, you may ask? That’s because any one of them will definitely give you more to talk about in your evaluation and accompanying explanation/elaborations.
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
T - 3
T - 3
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
T - 2
T - 2
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
T - 1
T - 1
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Some guiding questions:
how would you explain / elaborate on each thesis in the leadup to your first example (if necessary)?
how would you explain / elaborate your example to closely link to the question’s keywords, and so the evaluation after comes more naturally?
how would you connect each evaluation to the next example, or the next idea, insight, or claim you want to bring in?
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Some guiding questions:
how would you explain / elaborate on each thesis in the leadup to your first example (if necessary)?
how would you explain / elaborate your example to closely link to the question’s keywords, and so the evaluation after comes more naturally?
how would you connect each evaluation to the next example, or the next idea, insight, or claim you want to bring in?
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
T - 0
T - 0
Liftoff!
Liftoff!
Colour Code
Colour Code
Colour Code
We’ve made each paragraph really well-developed for learning purposes. However, this also means they can get a bit long.
As such, we have colour-coded the key parts of the factual examples, the key evaluations, and accompanying explanations/elaborations — these are the ones which we recommend looking at first.
We’ve made each paragraph really well-developed for learning purposes. However, this also means they can get a bit long.
As such, we have colour-coded the key parts of the factual examples, the key evaluations, and accompanying explanations/elaborations — these are the ones which we recommend looking at first.
Example
Factual evidence which supports your argument. However, the Example should not simply be a regurgitation of facts; phrases and keywords that explicitly link back to your thesis are necessary. For that reason, it is often intertwined with Elaboration and Explanation, as we shall see below.
Example
Factual evidence which supports your argument. However, the Example should not simply be a regurgitation of facts; phrases and keywords that explicitly link back to your thesis are necessary. For that reason, it is often intertwined with Elaboration and Explanation, as we shall see below.
Evaluation
Perhaps the most important part of the essay.
Demonstrates your personal judgement on the issue at hand or the idea being discussed.
Discusses the wider implications of your argument — what is at stake? who is affected? what are the consequences to society or the world?
Evaluation
Perhaps the most important part of the essay.
Demonstrates your personal judgement on the issue at hand or the idea being discussed.
Discusses the wider implications of your argument — what is at stake? who is affected? what are the consequences to society or the world?
Evaluation
Perhaps the most important part of the essay.
Demonstrates your personal judgement on the issue at hand or the idea being discussed.
Discusses the wider implications of your argument — what is at stake? who is affected? what are the consequences to society or the world?
Explanation/Elaborations
Explanations provide the justification and reasoning in support of the claim you’re making — answers the "why": “why is this so?” “what makes this convincing/true?” Elaborations develop the argument by pushing it to greater depth (causes, mechanisms), or greater breadth (impacts, implications).
Explanation/Elaborations
Explanations provide the justification and reasoning in support of the claim you’re making — answers the "why": “why is this so?” “what makes this convincing/true?” Elaborations develop the argument by pushing it to greater depth (causes, mechanisms), or greater breadth (impacts, implications).
Explanation/Elaborations
Explanations provide the justification and reasoning in support of the claim you’re making — answers the "why": “why is this so?” “what makes this convincing/true?” Elaborations develop the argument by pushing it to greater depth (causes, mechanisms), or greater breadth (impacts, implications).
Key Point
Important remarks we want you to take note of.
Key Point
Important remarks we want you to take note of.
For completeness, we’re going to run through arguments for both Disagree and Agree, and you can try doing a quick mental exercise before we reveal the content pointers for each paragraph — don’t worry, we’ll guide you along.
Let's Go!
For completeness, we’re going to run through arguments for both Disagree and Agree, and you can try doing a quick mental exercise before we reveal the content pointers for each paragraph — don’t worry, we’ll guide you along.
Let's Go!
For completeness, we’re going to run through arguments for both Disagree and Agree, and you can try doing a quick mental exercise before we reveal the content pointers for each paragraph — don’t worry, we’ll guide you along.
Let's Go!
Question Analysis
Question Analysis
Question Analysis
First, which GP domain(s) does this question fall under?
First, which GP domain(s) does this question fall under?
First, which GP domain(s) does this question fall under?
Click to reveal answer
Next, what are the keywords in the question?
Should the arts rely on government support?
Next, what are the keywords in the question?
Should the arts rely on government support?
Next, what are the keywords in the question?
Should the arts rely on government support?
Click to reveal answer
How should we interpret these keywords?
How should we interpret these keywords?
How should we interpret these keywords?
Click to reveal answer
The Hook
The Hook
The Hook
There is no “right” or “wrong” stance in GP — this is, and always will be, true.
However, what many don’t realise is that there sometimes is a stance which grants you more room to develop more complex thoughts, observations and insights; in other words, there can be a stance that's better to aim for high Content marks.
How do we know which is usually the better stance? As with all subjects, GP rewards you for more work and more thought, and so the stance that on first glance seems harder or counterintuitive to support is often the one you should tackle if you can.
In this case, agreeing is the stance which grants you more room to explore complex strands of thought. Disagreeing (i.e. arguing that the arts should rely on government support) not only surfaces garden-variety arguments which tend to recur in almost every script, but majority of those who attempt this question will also choose the Disagree stance, meaning you’ll be competing against more people as well .
That said, try to come up with at least 2 topic sentences first before committing; don’t force yourself to argue for a stance you have nothing to say about just because it “can” lead to higher marks. For learning purposes, these hook options are more suited for the Agree stance, due to the higher difficulty in arguing that the arts should not be supported by the state:
[Example] The origin of Wild Rice Theatre, Singapore
When Ivan Heng founded Singapore’s best-known theatre company in 2000, he named it Wild Rice: a staple that sustains the psyche of a nation, and yet one that grows free and untamed, taking root spontaneously within the substrate of society — and today, it remains a riveting idea of what art should be.
[History] The French Revolution and the Louvre
When French revolutionaries stormed the Louvre (in 1793) — then a king’s private palace — and declared its royal collection public, what they did not foresee was that within a decade the galleries would be filled with Napoleon’s plunder, and named after the new ruler; the state democratised art, but simultaneously decided what art would mean and who should be allowed to create it.
[Quote] From the speech which led to the creation of the US National Endowment for the Arts (NEA)
”Society must set the artist free to follow his vision wherever it takes him.” — former US president, John F. Kennedy
[Example] You can also summarise any one of the examples we use throughout the examiner’s report — each of them have been carefully picked such that they would also make thought-provoking hooks. Alternatively, you may use those which you have replaced with your own!
There is no “right” or “wrong” stance in GP — this is, and always will be, true.
However, what many don’t realise is that there sometimes is a stance which grants you more room to develop more complex thoughts, observations and insights; in other words, there can be a stance that's better to aim for high Content marks.
How do we know which is usually the better stance? As with all subjects, GP rewards you for more work and more thought, and so the stance that on first glance seems harder or counterintuitive to support is often the one you should tackle if you can.
In this case, agreeing is the stance which grants you more room to explore complex strands of thought. Disagreeing (i.e. arguing that the arts should rely on government support) not only surfaces garden-variety arguments which tend to recur in almost every script, but majority of those who attempt this question will also choose the Disagree stance, meaning you’ll be competing against more people as well .
That said, try to come up with at least 2 topic sentences first before committing; don’t force yourself to argue for a stance you have nothing to say about just because it “can” lead to higher marks. For learning purposes, these hook options are more suited for the Agree stance, due to the higher difficulty in arguing that the arts should not be supported by the state:
[Example] The origin of Wild Rice Theatre, Singapore
When Ivan Heng founded Singapore’s best-known theatre company in 2000, he named it Wild Rice: a staple that sustains the psyche of a nation, and yet one that grows free and untamed, taking root spontaneously within the substrate of society — and today, it remains a riveting idea of what art should be.
[History] The French Revolution and the Louvre
When French revolutionaries stormed the Louvre (in 1793) — then a king’s private palace — and declared its royal collection public, what they did not foresee was that within a decade the galleries would be filled with Napoleon’s plunder, and named after the new ruler; the state democratised art, but simultaneously decided what art would mean and who should be allowed to create it.
[Quote] From the speech which led to the creation of the US National Endowment for the Arts (NEA)
”Society must set the artist free to follow his vision wherever it takes him.” — former US president, John F. Kennedy
[Example] You can also summarise any one of the examples we use throughout the examiner’s report — each of them have been carefully picked such that they would also make thought-provoking hooks. Alternatively, you may use those which you have replaced with your own!
Antithesis 1
Antithesis 1
Antithesis 1
Hide Mental Exercise
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 1 (worked example)
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 1 (worked example)
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 1 (worked example)
T - 4
T - 4
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework will you use?
In my first antithesis I want to argue something along the lines of how the arts need government support in order to survive, and reach more people. Since this is a pretty straightforward claim with no paradox or appearance vs. reality involved, the likely framework is just standard layering.
Hints
What are the different functions which government support can achieve, which benefit the arts? Clearly there is financial support (i.e. funding); but there is also the point on the government opening state-owned venues to house the arts, as well as consumer-facing policies designed to help the arts flourish.
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
In my first antithesis I want to argue something along the lines of how the arts need government support in order to survive, and reach more people. Since this is a pretty straightforward claim with no paradox or appearance vs. reality involved, the likely framework is just standard layering.
Hints
What are the different functions which government support can achieve, which benefit the arts? Clearly there is financial support (i.e. funding); but there is also the point on the government opening state-owned venues to house the arts, as well as consumer-facing policies designed to help the arts flourish.
T - 3
T - 3
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Organising our thoughts by layer (i.e. the different functions which government support achieves)
Funding -> helps to alleviate pressures of soaring rental costs, high overhead costs, as well as income volatility.
Provision of state-owned venues -> eliminates the need for artists to independently seek out spaces to showcase their art, which may also incur additional costs like leasing.
Consumer-facing policies -> besides lowering financial barriers for consumers to enjoy art, they also allow art institutions / artists to access an audience they wouldn't be able to reach alone.
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Organising our thoughts by layer (i.e. the different functions which government support achieves)
Funding -> helps to alleviate pressures of soaring rental costs, high overhead costs, as well as income volatility.
Provision of state-owned venues -> eliminates the need for artists to independently seek out spaces to showcase their art, which may also incur additional costs like leasing.
Consumer-facing policies -> besides lowering financial barriers for consumers to enjoy art, they also allow art institutions / artists to access an audience they wouldn't be able to reach alone.
T - 2
T - 2
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them. Some well-known examples I can think of are 1) for funding: the US National Endowment for the Arts (NEA), 2) for venue provision: well-known museums like the Louvre in France and Tate Modern in the UK, 3) for consumer-facing policies: Singapore's "Arts for All" initiative, and free entry to museums in countries like the UK.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
For the US NEA example, the seal of approval which the NEA gives to chosen organisations also helps them attract corporate sponsors and private investment, since it's a symbol of credibility and quality. Also, with less financial pressure in general, artists can focus wholeheartedly on the artistic quality of their works rather than on matters like survival.
For the example of museums like the Louvre, it can also show how art that has historically been private / inaccessible can now be opened to the national public through government efforts
For the Singapore 'Arts for All' example, art brought into common spaces actually blurs the line between appreciation for the arts and everyday living, and brings the arts to the doorstep of citizens.
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them. Some well-known examples I can think of are 1) US scrapping their foreign aid programmes, 2) the back and forth of the US-Iran or Russia-Ukraine war, 3) the rearming of France and Germany after the US withdrew key military commitments towards its allies in Europe
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
For the US NEA example, the seal of approval which the NEA gives to chosen organisations also helps them attract corporate sponsors and private investment, since it's a symbol of credibility and quality. Also, with less financial pressure in general, artists can focus wholeheartedly on the artistic quality of their works rather than on matters like survival.
For the example of museums like the Louvre, it can also show how art that has historically been private / inaccessible can now be opened to the national public through government efforts
For the Singapore 'Arts for All' example, art brought into common spaces actually blurs the line between appreciation for the arts and everyday living, and brings the arts to the doorstep of citizens.
T - 1
T - 1
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Eg. For examples on financial support, I can bring up about how the volatility of income for many artists stems from fluctuating or unpredictable art viewership — since it is most frequently engaged in as a purely recreational pursuit.
Eg. For consumer-facing examples, I can also discuss how top-down policies allow members of the public who may otherwise lack the motivation to seek out art on their own, or lack knowledge regarding the existence of opportunities to explore various forms of art, to witness and enjoy it in close proximity. Moreover, when art enters communities, it can also be enjoyed by everyone regardless of identity.
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Eg. For examples on financial support, I can bring up about how the volatility of income for many artists stems from fluctuating or unpredictable art viewership — since it is most frequently engaged in as a purely recreational pursuit.
Eg. For consumer-facing examples, I can also discuss how top-down policies allow members of the public who may otherwise lack the motivation to seek out art on their own, or lack knowledge regarding the existence of opportunities to explore various forms of art, to witness and enjoy it in close proximity. Moreover, when art enters communities, it can also be enjoyed by everyone regardless of identity.
T - 0
T - 0
Liftoff!
Topic Sentence
The very accessibility and development of art is predicated on governmental support, which provides both the publicity and financial backing to sustain artistic propagation.
Topic Sentence
The very accessibility and development of art is predicated on governmental support, which provides both the publicity and financial backing to sustain artistic propagation.
Framework: Layering
Based on the various types of government support, shown in pink
Framework: Layering
Based on the various types of government support, shown in pink
Framework: Layering
Based on the various types of government support, shown in pink
To begin, the provision of state-owned or state-financed venues to house public showcases of art constitutes governmental support;
Example I: The Sydney Opera House. Built by the New South Wales government and owned by the state via a public trust, it is a monument not merely to architectural grandeur but artistic ambition — as the stage on which Australian opera, ballet and symphony have carved their name onto the global stage.
Example II: Museums from the Louvre in Paris to the Tate Modern in London have seen great art gain access to public spaces, where they can be appreciated by millions each year.
Not only does this eliminate the need for artists to independently chart spaces to gain public exposure, which may entail additional costs such as leasing,
but can even allow historically private collections (e.g. the Louvre’s treasures which were once hoarded by the king) to be expropriated and made visible to the public eye.
Moreover, state support also manifests directly in the form of funding to alleviate financial pressures;
Example I. In the US, the National Endowment for the Arts (NEA) not only distributes hundreds of millions a year in aid packages to local arts organisations, but its grants act as a de facto “seal of approval” that further attracts corporate sponsors and private investment.
Example II. France’s intermittents du spectacle: a unique social security scheme which pays performers and technicians in the arts scene between gigs, it is often cited as the reason for its vibrant arts landscape with many thriving small companies, festivals and “neighbourhood” productions.
In this way, practitioners of art can be insulated from the sobering realities of soaring rental costs, overhead expenditures and the vagaries of income from fluctuating art viewership — since it is most frequently engaged in as a purely recreational pursuit.
Simultaneously, it enables them to unreservedly channel their resources and efforts towards virtuosity and artistic quality rather than spending them on basic matters of survival.
At the same time, the government can also curate consumer-facing policies — including publicity and direct subsidies — which expand the influence of art.
Example I. Dependence on support from England’s Arts Council (ACE), for instance, entails free entrance to national museums and thereby dismantles consumer-end financial barriers which may otherwise deter citizens from engaging with art.
Example II. SG National Arts Council’s “Arts for All” initiative brings art into public spaces (e.g. through community performances, arts workshops). This blurs the line between aesthetic appreciation and the regularities of daily living, while expanding the reach of the arts to those who may otherwise lack the impetus to seek them out on their own, or not be cognisant of the existence of opportunities to explore various forms of art.
This means that top-down initiatives can effectively allow the influence of the arts to intersect with audiences it would otherwise be unable to reach alone, but whose participation is integral to the propagation of art as a democratic pursuit — one that can be enjoyed by people from all walks of life, irrespective of background or demographic.
Note: In each paragraph, it’s very useful to tap on local examples which you might be familiar with! However, since the scope of this question is International, a good rule of thumb is to not use more than ONE local example per para.
To begin, the provision of state-owned or state-financed venues to house public showcases of art constitutes governmental support;
Example I: The Sydney Opera House. Built by the New South Wales government and owned by the state via a public trust, it is a monument not merely to architectural grandeur but artistic ambition — as the stage on which Australian opera, ballet and symphony have carved their name onto the global stage.
Example II: Museums from the Louvre in Paris to the Tate Modern in London have seen great art gain access to public spaces, where they can be appreciated by millions each year.
Not only does this eliminate the need for artists to independently chart spaces to gain public exposure, which may entail additional costs such as leasing,
but can even allow historically private collections (e.g. the Louvre’s treasures which were once hoarded by the king) to be expropriated and made visible to the public eye.
Moreover, state support also manifests directly in the form of funding to alleviate financial pressures;
Example I. In the US, the National Endowment for the Arts (NEA) not only distributes hundreds of millions a year in aid packages to local arts organisations, but its grants act as a de facto “seal of approval” that further attracts corporate sponsors and private investment.
Example II. France’s intermittents du spectacle: a unique social security scheme which pays performers and technicians in the arts scene between gigs, it is often cited as the reason for its vibrant arts landscape with many thriving small companies, festivals and “neighbourhood” productions.
In this way, practitioners of art can be insulated from the sobering realities of soaring rental costs, overhead expenditures and the vagaries of income from fluctuating art viewership — since it is most frequently engaged in as a purely recreational pursuit.
Simultaneously, it enables them to unreservedly channel their resources and efforts towards virtuosity and artistic quality rather than spending them on basic matters of survival.
At the same time, the government can also curate consumer-facing policies — including publicity and direct subsidies — which expand the influence of art.
Example I. Dependence on support from England’s Arts Council (ACE), for instance, entails free entrance to national museums and thereby dismantles consumer-end financial barriers which may otherwise deter citizens from engaging with art.
Example II. SG National Arts Council’s “Arts for All” initiative brings art into public spaces (e.g. through community performances, arts workshops). This blurs the line between aesthetic appreciation and the regularities of daily living, while expanding the reach of the arts to those who may otherwise lack the impetus to seek them out on their own, or not be cognisant of the existence of opportunities to explore various forms of art.
This means that top-down initiatives can effectively allow the influence of the arts to intersect with audiences it would otherwise be unable to reach alone, but whose participation is integral to the propagation of art as a democratic pursuit — one that can be enjoyed by people from all walks of life, irrespective of background or demographic.
Note: In each paragraph, it’s very useful to tap on local examples which you might be familiar with! However, since the scope of this question is International, a good rule of thumb is to not use more than ONE local example per para.
To begin, the provision of state-owned or state-financed venues to house public showcases of art constitutes governmental support;
Example I: The Sydney Opera House. Built by the New South Wales government and owned by the state via a public trust, it is a monument not merely to architectural grandeur but artistic ambition — as the stage on which Australian opera, ballet and symphony have carved their name onto the global stage.
Example II: Museums from the Louvre in Paris to the Tate Modern in London have seen great art gain access to public spaces, where they can be appreciated by millions each year.
Not only does this eliminate the need for artists to independently chart spaces to gain public exposure, which may entail additional costs such as leasing,
but can even allow historically private collections (e.g. the Louvre’s treasures which were once hoarded by the king) to be expropriated and made visible to the public eye.
Moreover, state support also manifests directly in the form of funding to alleviate financial pressures;
Example I. In the US, the National Endowment for the Arts (NEA) not only distributes hundreds of millions a year in aid packages to local arts organisations, but its grants act as a de facto “seal of approval” that further attracts corporate sponsors and private investment.
Example II. France’s intermittents du spectacle: a unique social security scheme which pays performers and technicians in the arts scene between gigs, it is often cited as the reason for its vibrant arts landscape with many thriving small companies, festivals and “neighbourhood” productions.
In this way, practitioners of art can be insulated from the sobering realities of soaring rental costs, overhead expenditures and the vagaries of income from fluctuating art viewership — since it is most frequently engaged in as a purely recreational pursuit.
Simultaneously, it enables them to unreservedly channel their resources and efforts towards virtuosity and artistic quality rather than spending them on basic matters of survival.
At the same time, the government can also curate consumer-facing policies — including publicity and direct subsidies — which expand the influence of art.
Example I. Dependence on support from England’s Arts Council (ACE), for instance, entails free entrance to national museums and thereby dismantles consumer-end financial barriers which may otherwise deter citizens from engaging with art.
Example II. SG National Arts Council’s “Arts for All” initiative brings art into public spaces (e.g. through community performances, arts workshops). This blurs the line between aesthetic appreciation and the regularities of daily living, while expanding the reach of the arts to those who may otherwise lack the impetus to seek them out on their own, or not be cognisant of the existence of opportunities to explore various forms of art.
This means that top-down initiatives can effectively allow the influence of the arts to intersect with audiences it would otherwise be unable to reach alone, but whose participation is integral to the propagation of art as a democratic pursuit — one that can be enjoyed by people from all walks of life, irrespective of background or demographic.
Note: In each paragraph, it’s very useful to tap on local examples which you might be familiar with! However, since the scope of this question is International, a good rule of thumb is to not use more than ONE local example per para.
Antithesis 2
Antithesis 2
Antithesis 2
Hide Mental Exercise
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 2
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 2
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 2
T - 4
T - 4
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
If artists or art institutions do require support, what are the possible sources they can get it from? As such, if the arts do not rely on government support, who might they turn to?
What might be some disadvantages or risks of resorting to the source you have identified in (a), as compared to the government?
Why do you think these disadvantages or risks exist?
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
If artists or art institutions do require support, what are the possible sources they can get it from? As such, if the arts do not rely on government support, who might they turn to?
What might be some disadvantages or risks of resorting to the source you have identified in (a), as compared to the government?
Why do you think these disadvantages or risks exist?
T - 3
T - 3
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
Going back to the question which we posed in Question Analysis — do you think "the Arts" refers only to the final product you see? what goes on behind the scenes that is nonetheless essential? what might be the impact of a lack of government support on this foundation?
Are great works of art created on the first try? What usually happens in the process? Thus, what might be a possible problem of relying on the non-governmental sources of support?
Another advantage the government has over any other type of organisation is the stability that it offers. Considering the larger economic environment, how might this be beneficial to the arts sector?
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
Going back to the question which we posed in Question Analysis — do you think "the Arts" refers only to the final product you see? what goes on behind the scenes that is nonetheless essential? what might be the impact of a lack of government support on this foundation?
Are great works of art created on the first try? What usually happens in the process? Thus, what might be a possible problem of relying on the non-governmental sources of support?
Another advantage the government has over any other type of organisation is the stability that it offers. Considering the larger economic environment, how might this be beneficial to the arts sector?
T - 2
T - 2
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
All of us know about the influence of K-Pop today, but how did it start out?
There are many famous Broadway plays today, such as Hamilton and Les Miserables (which recently came to Singapore) — did they come from commercial, private-owned theatres?
What are some countries you know of that have government support schemes for the arts (excluding Singapore?)
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
All of us know about the influence of K-Pop today, but how did it start out?
There are many famous Broadway plays today, such as Hamilton and Les Miserables (which recently came to Singapore) — did they come from commercial, private-owned theatres?
What are some countries you know of that have government support schemes for the arts (excluding Singapore?)
T - 1
T - 1
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
What are necessary foundations of the arts industry?
Think about the "alternative sources of funding" we mentioned previously: what are its patrons hoping to get in return? for countries with nascent or immature arts sectors, would they be incentivised to fund these industries and why?
What does the government need to maintain or uphold, that makes its support much more stable and reliable than these "alternative sources"?
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
What are necessary foundations of the arts industry?
Think about the "alternative sources of funding" we mentioned previously: what are its patrons hoping to get in return? for countries with nascent or immature arts sectors, would they be incentivised to fund these industries and why?
What does the government need to maintain or uphold, that makes its support much more stable and reliable than these "alternative sources"?
T - 0
T - 0
Liftoff!
Liftoff!
Topic Sentence
Unlike private investment which tends to be subjected to the whims and speculations of patrons, government support is more likely to sustain the long-term vibrancy of the arts sector once secured.
Topic Sentence
Unlike private investment which tends to be subjected to the whims and speculations of patrons, government support is more likely to sustain the long-term vibrancy of the arts sector once secured.
Framework: Layering
Based on how government support benefits different aspects of the arts industry.
Framework: Layering
Based on how government support benefits different aspects of the arts industry.
Framework: Layering
Based on how government support benefits different aspects of the arts industry.
Crucially, the infrastructure which underpins any arts sector extends beyond what is presented on stages and exhibited in museum halls, for sustaining them are pipelines dedicated to both the nurturing of artistic talent, and the creation of original works.
Yet, in their nascency, these projects are unlikely to draw private capital not simply due to thin profit margins, but the fact that no compelling projection of the inroads they could make in the market prior to the creation of any concrete “deliverables”.
Example I. The History of K-Pop: Long before the ascendancy of K-pop and the Korean Wave backed by private labels, Korea’s artistic exports were incubated by public capital. In the wake of the 1997 financial crisis, the government committed growing shares of the national budget to the cultural landscape as private investors retreated, and defended a screen quota that reserved cinema days for domestic films (even as Hollywood blockbusters promised rapid economic gains).
Example II. Broadway Theatre in the US. Though viewed as the pinnacle of theatrical production which operates on a commercial basis, a good portion of its notable productions — including Hamilton and Les Miserables — have their origin in the non-profit sector: regional theatres funded by the NEA, state arts councils, city cultural departments. The performers themselves, too, are predominantly supplied by state-owned conservatories and training programs in public universities.
Particularly for countries with a burgeoning arts scene (e.g. Thailand) that inevitably lacks substantial investment potential at present, state support is arguably irreplaceable to sustain the infrastructure and platforms necessary to propel these sectors closer to self-sufficiency, or minimally advance them to a point in development where they can become a receptacle for private investment.
Moreover, great or canonical works — a case in point being the Broadway productions — are typically created from many rounds of iteration and trial-and-error. Where the private sector may demand consistent results or lack the tolerance for repeated failures within a defined horizon, only government support may be able to provide an environment relatively insulated from the underlying risks of creative experimentation, thereby laying the groundwork for the advancement of the arts in the long run.
At the very least, government funding can act as safeguard against unforeseeable externalities such as poor market forecasts or economic downturns.
Example I. The UK arts scene’s “three-way” split: receiving 1/3 of their funding from the government, 1/3 from box office sales, and 1/3 from private sponsors → even for countries with an established arts scene, diversification of its funding sources beyond the private sphere remains imperative for long-term stability.
A very useful strategy when presenting an international example is to use the characteristics of that particular country to further reinforce that your claim will likely be even more true in other countries, using the signpost “Even…”
Example II. Thailand’s Govt Support Schemes: in 2024, the Thailand Creative Content Agency (THACCA) was established particularly to help an inchoate [immature, underdeveloped] arts sector develop and recover from the economic shocks of the Covid-19 pandemic.
Private capital, which inevitably hinges on some kind of profit motive or economic rationality, is often easily swayed by market trends. In turn, private funding for sectors that have yet to find their feet may dwindle or even completely cease amidst times of volatility — a predicament which the arts scene by itself cannot weather without sacrificing creative output.
In comparison, government support is anchored in national budgets and legislative mandates, and this layer of accountability solidifies a foundation for the arts scene to prioritise artistic quality, rather than being fixated on appealing to consumers’ tastes (to draw ticket sales).
Note: since our topic sentence already makes explicit the comparison between private and public funding that we’re making, we must analyse this in our Evaluation too — i.e. why is public funding more reliable and consistent compared to private capital? what are the qualities / characteristics of each?
Crucially, the infrastructure which underpins any arts sector extends beyond what is presented on stages and exhibited in museum halls, for sustaining them are pipelines dedicated to both the nurturing of artistic talent, and the creation of original works.
Yet, in their nascency, these projects are unlikely to draw private capital not simply due to thin profit margins, but the fact that no compelling projection of the inroads they could make in the market prior to the creation of any concrete “deliverables”.
Example I. The History of K-Pop: Long before the ascendancy of K-pop and the Korean Wave backed by private labels, Korea’s artistic exports were incubated by public capital. In the wake of the 1997 financial crisis, the government committed growing shares of the national budget to the cultural landscape as private investors retreated, and defended a screen quota that reserved cinema days for domestic films (even as Hollywood blockbusters promised rapid economic gains).
Example II. Broadway Theatre in the US. Though viewed as the pinnacle of theatrical production which operates on a commercial basis, a good portion of its notable productions — including Hamilton and Les Miserables — have their origin in the non-profit sector: regional theatres funded by the NEA, state arts councils, city cultural departments.The performers themselves, too, are predominantly supplied by state-owned conservatories and training programs in public universities.
Particularly for countries with a burgeoning arts scene (e.g. Thailand) that inevitably lacks substantial investment potential at present, state support is arguably irreplaceable to sustain the infrastructure and platforms necessary to propel these sectors closer to self-sufficiency, or minimally advance them to a point in development where they can become a receptacle for private investment.
Moreover, great or canonical works — a case in point being the Broadway productions — are typically created from many rounds of iteration and trial-and-error. Where the private sector may demand consistent results or lack the tolerance for repeated failures within a defined horizon, only government support may be able to provide an environment relatively insulated from the underlying risks of creative experimentation, thereby laying the groundwork for the advancement of the arts in the long run.
At the very least, government funding can act as safeguard against unforeseeable externalities such as poor market forecasts or economic downturns.
Example I. The UK arts scene’s “three-way” split: receiving 1/3 of their funding from the government, 1/3 from box office sales, and 1/3 from private sponsors → even for countries with an established arts scene, diversification of its funding sources beyond the private sphere remains imperative for long-term stability.
A very useful strategy when presenting an international example is to use the characteristics of that particular country to further reinforce that your claim will likely be even more true in other countries, using the signpost “Even…”
Example II. Thailand’s Govt Support Schemes: in 2024, the Thailand Creative Content Agency (THACCA) was established particularly to help an inchoate [immature, underdeveloped] arts sector develop and recover from the economic shocks of the Covid-19 pandemic.
Private capital, which inevitably hinges on some kind of profit motive or economic rationality, is often easily swayed by market trends. In turn, private funding for sectors that have yet to find their feet may dwindle or even completely cease amidst times of volatility — a predicament which the arts scene by itself cannot weather without sacrificing creative output.
In comparison, government support is anchored in national budgets and legislative mandates, and this layer of accountability solidifies a foundation for the arts scene to prioritise artistic quality, rather than being fixated on appealing to consumers’ tastes (to draw ticket sales).
Note: since our topic sentence already makes explicit the comparison between private and public funding that we’re making, we must analyse this in our Evaluation too — i.e. why is public funding more reliable and consistent compared to private capital? what are the qualities / characteristics of each?
Crucially, the infrastructure which underpins any arts sector extends beyond what is presented on stages and exhibited in museum halls, for sustaining them are pipelines dedicated to both the nurturing of artistic talent, and the creation of original works.
Yet, in their nascency, these projects are unlikely to draw private capital not simply due to thin profit margins, but the fact that no compelling projection of the inroads they could make in the market prior to the creation of any concrete “deliverables”.
Example I. The History of K-Pop: Long before the ascendancy of K-pop and the Korean Wave backed by private labels, Korea’s artistic exports were incubated by public capital. In the wake of the 1997 financial crisis, the government committed growing shares of the national budget to the cultural landscape as private investors retreated, and defended a screen quota that reserved cinema days for domestic films (even as Hollywood blockbusters promised rapid economic gains).
Example II. Broadway Theatre in the US. Though viewed as the pinnacle of theatrical production which operates on a commercial basis, a good portion of its notable productions — including Hamilton and Les Miserables — have their origin in the non-profit sector: regional theatres funded by the NEA, state arts councils, city cultural departments. The performers themselves, too, are predominantly supplied by state-owned conservatories and training programs in public universities.
Particularly for countries with a burgeoning arts scene (e.g. Thailand) that inevitably lacks substantial investment potential at present, state support is arguably irreplaceable to sustain the infrastructure and platforms necessary to propel these sectors closer to self-sufficiency, or minimally advance them to a point in development where they can become a receptacle for private investment.
Moreover, great or canonical works — a case in point being the Broadway productions — are typically created from many rounds of iteration and trial-and-error. Where the private sector may demand consistent results or lack the tolerance for repeated failures within a defined horizon, only government support may be able to provide an environment relatively insulated from the underlying risks of creative experimentation, thereby laying the groundwork for the advancement of the arts in the long run.
At the very least, government funding can act as safeguard against unforeseeable externalities such as poor market forecasts or economic downturns.
Example I. The UK arts scene’s “three-way” split: receiving 1/3 of their funding from the government, 1/3 from box office sales, and 1/3 from private sponsors → even for countries with an established arts scene, diversification of its funding sources beyond the private sphere remains imperative for long-term stability.
A very useful strategy when presenting an international example is to use the characteristics of that particular country to further reinforce that your claim will likely be even more true in other countries, using the signpost “Even…”
Example II. Thailand’s Govt Support Schemes: in 2024, the Thailand Creative Content Agency (THACCA) was established particularly to help an inchoate [immature, underdeveloped] arts sector develop and recover from the economic shocks of the Covid-19 pandemic.
Private capital, which inevitably hinges on some kind of profit motive or economic rationality, is often easily swayed by market trends. In turn, private funding for sectors that have yet to find their feet may dwindle or even completely cease amidst times of volatility — a predicament which the arts scene by itself cannot weather without sacrificing creative output.
In comparison, government support is anchored in national budgets and legislative mandates, and this layer of accountability solidifies a foundation for the arts scene to prioritise artistic quality, rather than being fixated on appealing to consumers’ tastes (to draw ticket sales).
Note: since our topic sentence already makes explicit the comparison between private and public funding that we’re making, we must analyse this in our Evaluation too — i.e. why is public funding more reliable and consistent compared to private capital? what are the qualities / characteristics of each?
A General Hint for the Theses
While the question seems to be on Arts & Culture, don't let your thinking be strictly confined within this domain — think about what other broad areas or topics in GP might you be able to link to, given that this question deals with not just the Arts, but with the government.
Now, onto the Theses.
A General Hint for the Theses
While the question seems to be on Arts & Culture, don't let your thinking be strictly confined within this domain — think about what other broad areas or topics in GP might you be able to link to, given that this question deals with not just the Arts, but with the government.
Now, onto the Theses.
A General Hint for the Theses
While the question seems to be on Arts & Culture, don't let your thinking be strictly confined within this domain — think about what other broad areas or topics in GP might you be able to link to, given that this question deals with not just the Arts, but with the government.
Now, onto the Theses.
Thesis 1
Thesis 1
Thesis 1
Hide Mental Exercise
Mental Exercise For Thesis 1
Mental Exercise For Thesis 1
Mental Exercise For Thesis 1
T - 4
T - 4
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
Look back at Disagree TS 1. It claims that accessibility depends on state venues and funding — but what conception of “the arts” does that claim quietly assume? Is a museum or a national theatre the only place art happens?
Think of the last piece of art you encountered that was not in an institution — on a wall, in a train station, on your phone. Who paid for it? Who approved it? Did it need either?
If art can flourish without any of the infrastructure Disagree TS 1 describes, what does that tell you about where art’s power actually comes from? (The irony: the “support” may be addressing something art never needed.)
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
Look back at Disagree TS 1. It claims that accessibility depends on state venues and funding — but what conception of “the arts” does that claim quietly assume? Is a museum or a national theatre the only place art happens?
Think of the last piece of art you encountered that was not in an institution — on a wall, in a train station, on your phone. Who paid for it? Who approved it? Did it need either?
If art can flourish without any of the infrastructure Disagree TS 1 describes, what does that tell you about where art’s power actually comes from? (The irony: the “support” may be addressing something art never needed.)
T - 3
T - 3
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
Why might a work that nobody commissioned carry more weight than one that was? What does the absence of a patron do to an artwork’s credibility as social critique?
When art is made by a community rather than delivered by an institution, who ends up participating? What does that do to the social function of art, beyond its aesthetic one?
What stereotype about the arts (who it’s for, where it lives) does ground-up art dismantle? Why does dismantling that stereotype matter to the question?
Does curation, scripting or rehearsal add to art — or can it subtract something? What is that something?
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
Why might a work that nobody commissioned carry more weight than one that was? What does the absence of a patron do to an artwork’s credibility as social critique?
When art is made by a community rather than delivered by an institution, who ends up participating? What does that do to the social function of art, beyond its aesthetic one?
What stereotype about the arts (who it’s for, where it lives) does ground-up art dismantle? Why does dismantling that stereotype matter to the question?
Does curation, scripting or rehearsal add to art — or can it subtract something? What is that something?
T - 2
T - 2
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
Think of a street artist whose work gains international attention in part because the authorities keep trying to remove it. What does this prove about where the work’s power lies?
Recall a recent protest movement that expressed itself through art on city walls, made by ordinary people rather than professionals. Who joined in — and what does this illustrate about the function of art?
Have you seen art performed in everyday spaces with no institution behind it — a train station, a street corner, a bar?
Is there a festival anywhere in the world where anyone can perform anything without being selected?
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
Think of a street artist whose work gains international attention in part because the authorities keep trying to remove it. What does this prove about where the work’s power lies?
Recall a recent protest movement that expressed itself through art on city walls, made by ordinary people rather than professionals. Who joined in — and what does this illustrate about the function of art?
Have you seen art performed in everyday spaces with no institution behind it — a train station, a street corner, a bar?
Is there a festival anywhere in the world where anyone can perform anything without being selected?
T - 1
T - 1
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
In what way can communal art improve social unity or cohesion (clue: who can participate)?
What do you think is the purest form of the arts — art that emerges with, or without external support? What do you think is the purpose of art in its purest form?
What is a common stereotype associated with the arts, and how could this new conceptualisation of the arts address that?
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
In what way can communal art improve social unity or cohesion (clue: who can participate)?
What do you think is the purest form of the arts — art that emerges with, or without external support? What do you think is the purpose of art in its purest form?
What is a common stereotype associated with the arts, and how could this new conceptualisation of the arts address that?
T - 0
T - 0
Liftoff!
Liftoff!
Topic Sentence
A lack of external support — be it logistical or financial — does not preclude the flourishing of the arts. In fact, it may actually foreground the fundamental characteristic of artistic expression: as an organic and spontaneous product of human creativity.
Topic Sentence
A lack of external support — be it logistical or financial — does not preclude the flourishing of the arts. In fact, it may actually foreground the fundamental characteristic of artistic expression: as an organic and spontaneous product of human creativity.
Topic Sentence
A lack of external support — be it logistical or financial — does not preclude the flourishing of the arts. In fact, it may actually foreground the fundamental characteristic of artistic expression: as an organic and spontaneous product of human creativity.
Framework: Irony / Paradox
In relation to how the arts may actually reveal their true power when allowed to flourish independently.
Framework: Irony / Paradox
In relation to how the arts may actually reveal their true power when allowed to flourish independently.
Framework: Irony / Paradox
In relation to how the arts may actually reveal their true power when allowed to flourish independently.
Coincidentally, this topic sentence presents an opposing view to our first Antithesis (Disagree, TS 1), thus we will present this paragraph in the format of a rebuttal. If you would like to use it as a regular body paragraph, all you have to do is cut out the first few lines which address the Antithesis.
While both state funding and publicity may be integral to broadening the reach of different art forms [Concession], this view ultimately rests on a conception of the Arts that is formal and institutionalised.
Yet the true power of art is evident when its expression is unfettered by any organisational structure, and unconstrained by time or venue.
Example I. Banksy’s graffiti art: In the UK, the elusive street artist has long received international acclaim for his street murals which intertwine creative flair with a distinct satirical edge: for instance, his famous immigration mural — which sharply juxtaposes a group of dull gray pigeons wielding protest banners against a colourful, migratory swallow — became an overnight sensation even as it was promptly torn down by authorities.
Yet the gravity of the social critique embodied by such works, along with their capacity to give voice to the marginalised, arises precisely because they are uncommissioned, and unsanctioned — appearing overnight on property the artist does not even own.
Example II. #SprayTheirName (2020). Bearing the legacy of the Black Lives Matter (BLM) protests, this was an artistic movement sweeping across the US which saw both white and coloured communities working together to spray-paint portraits of Black citizens on city walls; not just to commemorate direct victims of police violence — including George Floyd and Breonna Taylor — but to capture the stories of individuals who have been systematically oppressed, neglected or silenced due to racial inequities.
This hints at how the true authenticity and visceral impact of art is most pronounced when it is allowed to flourish spontaneously from the ground up.
Such forms of communal art can also go a long way in fostering social unity: by attracting a diverse makeup of artists extending well beyond the demographic of its initial creators.
In doing so, we arguably pay more homage to art as a discipline — one that seeks to organically reflect, honour, and immortalise parts of our life and being.
Example III. Busking / spontaneous performances: One only has to look at the array of musical or magic performances across the London Underground, the many buskers in Singapore who bring their craft to everyday spaces, or even the spontaneous improvisation of a jazz band in a New York bar lounge…
Alternatively, you can bring in open-access art festivals (e.g. the Edinburgh Fringe) where anyone can perform any kind of art, from opera to instrumentals, so long as they can find space to do so — no license or registration required!
^Technically, the government cannot prohibit these activities for them to take place. However, we will not be equating that with “government support” in this essay, so that there is meaningful room to argue FOR the stance in the question (otherwise, by that logic everything that happens in the country would require “government support”, and the essay question would become trivial).
As such, decoupling art from state support not only dismantles the stereotype of art as a pursuit enclosed within grand, highfalutin institutions, distant from the lives of the common man…
but constitutes a bold statement that art will always be all around us even without the crutches of authority, poised to enliven and inspire the lives of each individual.
In this view, art can flourish equally well if not better when unmediated by an external party, compared to a version which has been deliberately curated, scripted, or even rehearsed.
Coincidentally, this topic sentence presents an opposing view to our first Antithesis (Disagree, TS 1), thus we will present this paragraph in the format of a rebuttal. If you would like to use it as a regular body paragraph, all you have to do is cut out the first few lines which address the Antithesis.
While both state funding and publicity may be integral to broadening the reach of different art forms [Concession], this view ultimately rests on a conception of the Arts that is formal and institutionalised.
Yet the true power of art is evident when its expression is unfettered by any organisational structure, and unconstrained by time or venue.
Example I. Banksy’s graffiti art: In the UK, the elusive street artist has long received international acclaim for his street murals which intertwine creative flair with a distinct satirical edge: for instance, his famous immigration mural — which sharply juxtaposes a group of dull gray pigeons wielding protest banners against a colourful, migratory swallow — became an overnight sensation even as it was promptly torn down by authorities.
Yet the gravity of the social critique embodied by such works, along with their capacity to give voice to the marginalised, arises precisely because they are uncommissioned, and unsanctioned — appearing overnight on property the artist does not even own.
Example II. #SprayTheirName (2020). Bearing the legacy of the Black Lives Matter (BLM) protests, this was an artistic movement sweeping across the US which saw both white and coloured communities working together to spray-paint portraits of Black citizens on city walls; not just to commemorate direct victims of police violence — including George Floyd and Breonna Taylor — but to capture the stories of individuals who have been systematically oppressed, neglected or silenced due to racial inequities.
This hints at how the true authenticity and visceral impact of art is most pronounced when it is allowed to flourish spontaneously from the ground up.
Such forms of communal art can also go a long way in fostering social unity: by attracting a diverse makeup of artists extending well beyond the demographic of its initial creators.
In doing so, we arguably pay more homage to art as a discipline — one that seeks to organically reflect, honour, and immortalise parts of our life and being.
Example III. Busking / spontaneous performances: One only has to look at the array of musical or magic performances across the London Underground, the many buskers in Singapore who bring their craft to everyday spaces, or even the spontaneous improvisation of a jazz band in a New York bar lounge…
Alternatively, you can bring in open-access art festivals (e.g. the Edinburgh Fringe) where anyone can perform any kind of art, from opera to instrumentals, so long as they can find space to do so — no license or registration required!
^Technically, the government cannot prohibit these activities for them to take place. However, we will not be equating that with “government support” in this essay, so that there is meaningful room to argue FOR the stance in the question (otherwise, by that logic everything that happens in the country would require “government support”, and the essay question would become trivial).
As such, decoupling art from state support not only dismantles the stereotype of art as a pursuit enclosed within grand, highfalutin institutions, distant from the lives of the common man…
but constitutes a bold statement that art will always be all around us even without the crutches of authority, poised to enliven and inspire the lives of each individual.
In this view, art can flourish equally well if not better when unmediated by an external party, compared to a version which has been deliberately curated, scripted, or even rehearsed.
Coincidentally, this topic sentence presents an opposing view to our first Antithesis (Disagree, TS 1), thus we will present this paragraph in the format of a rebuttal. If you would like to use it as a regular body paragraph, all you have to do is cut out the first few lines which address the Antithesis.
While both state funding and publicity may be integral to broadening the reach of different art forms [Concession], this view ultimately rests on a conception of the Arts that is formal and institutionalised.
Yet the true power of art is evident when its expression is unfettered by any organisational structure, and unconstrained by time or venue.
Example I. Banksy’s graffiti art: In the UK, the elusive street artist has long received international acclaim for his street murals which intertwine creative flair with a distinct satirical edge: for instance, his famous immigration mural — which sharply juxtaposes a group of dull gray pigeons wielding protest banners against a colourful, migratory swallow — became an overnight sensation even as it was promptly torn down by authorities.
Yet the gravity of the social critique embodied by such works, along with their capacity to give voice to the marginalised, arises precisely because they are uncommissioned, and unsanctioned — appearing overnight on property the artist does not even own.
Example II. #SprayTheirName (2020). Bearing the legacy of the Black Lives Matter (BLM) protests, this was an artistic movement sweeping across the US which saw both white and coloured communities working together to spray-paint portraits of Black citizens on city walls; not just to commemorate direct victims of police violence — including George Floyd and Breonna Taylor — but to capture the stories of individuals who have been systematically oppressed, neglected or silenced due to racial inequities.
This hints at how the true authenticity and visceral impact of art is most pronounced when it is allowed to flourish spontaneously from the ground up.
Such forms of communal art can also go a long way in fostering social unity: by attracting a diverse makeup of artists extending well beyond the demographic of its initial creators.
In doing so, we arguably pay more homage to art as a discipline — one that seeks to organically reflect, honour, and immortalise parts of our life and being.
Example III. Busking / spontaneous performances: One only has to look at the array of musical or magic performances across the London Underground, the many buskers in Singapore who bring their craft to everyday spaces, or even the spontaneous improvisation of a jazz band in a New York bar lounge…
Alternatively, you can bring in open-access art festivals (e.g. the Edinburgh Fringe) where anyone can perform any kind of art, from opera to instrumentals, so long as they can find space to do so — no license or registration required!
^Technically, the government cannot prohibit these activities for them to take place. However, we will not be equating that with “government support” in this essay, so that there is meaningful room to argue FOR the stance in the question (otherwise, by that logic everything that happens in the country would require “government support”, and the essay question would become trivial).
As such, decoupling art from state support not only dismantles the stereotype of art as a pursuit enclosed within grand, highfalutin institutions, distant from the lives of the common man…
but constitutes a bold statement that art will always be all around us even without the crutches of authority, poised to enliven and inspire the lives of each individual.
In this view, art can flourish equally well if not better when unmediated by an external party, compared to a version which has been deliberately curated, scripted, or even rehearsed.
Thesis 2
Thesis 2
Thesis 2
Hide Mental Exercise
Mental Exercise For Thesis 2
Mental Exercise For Thesis 2
Mental Exercise For Thesis 2
T - 4
T - 4
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
Is money ever unconditional? When a government funds an artist, what does it expect in return — explicitly, and implicitly?
What is the purpose of art that makes this exchange so damaging? What must art be free to do that a patron might not want done?
“Support” sounds harmless — that’s the appearance. What is the reality beneath it? (Think: leverage, dependence, the ability to withdraw support at any time.)
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
Is money ever unconditional? When a government funds an artist, what does it expect in return — explicitly, and implicitly?
What is the purpose of art that makes this exchange so damaging? What must art be free to do that a patron might not want done?
“Support” sounds harmless — that’s the appearance. What is the reality beneath it? (Think: leverage, dependence, the ability to withdraw support at any time.)
T - 3
T - 3
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
Who actually does the censoring — the government, or the artist themselves in anticipation? Which of the two is harder to detect, and therefore more concerning?
Does this risk shrink or grow as state support becomes more generous? What does that say about the relationship between the size of support and the size of the danger?
Zoom out from the individual artist: what happens to a society whose art has been shaped by the state for a generation? What do citizens come to mistake for truth?
Does this only apply in authoritarian states? Try the “even in..” technique: if it happens even in liberal democracies where free speech is highly valued, what does this mean for everywhere else?
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
Who actually does the censoring — the government, or the artist themselves in anticipation? Which of the two is harder to detect, and therefore more concerning?
Does this risk shrink or grow as state support becomes more generous? What does that say about the relationship between the size of support and the size of the danger?
Zoom out from the individual artist: what happens to a society whose art has been shaped by the state for a generation? What do citizens come to mistake for truth?
Does this only apply in authoritarian states? Try the “even in..” technique: if it happens even in liberal democracies where free speech is highly valued, what does this mean for everywhere else?
T - 2
T - 2
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
Recall a case in which a federally funded national museum was instructed by the government to ban an exhibition due to “improper” perspectives.
Think of a case where the production of a canonical play at a major theatre was pulled over political references. Which references were these, and whose concerns?
In Singapore, do you know of playwrights, writers or artists who have seen their work censored or banned from airing / publishing?
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
Recall a case in which a federally funded national museum was instructed by the government to ban an exhibition due to “improper” perspectives.
Think of a case where the production of a canonical play at a major theatre was pulled over political references. Which references were these, and whose concerns?
In Singapore, do you know of playwrights, writers or artists who have seen their work censored or banned from airing / publishing?
T - 1
T - 1
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
Trace the chain of causality explicitly: how may government support ultimately lead to the arts losing their political autonomy? (funding → ____ → ____ → ____ → art as an instrument for those in power).
Does this problem get better or worse the more reliant the arts are on government support?
How should you connect the individual artist’s loss to the loss experienced by society as a whole?
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
Trace the chain of causality explicitly: how may government support ultimately lead to the arts losing their political autonomy? (funding → ____ → ____ → ____ → art as an instrument for those in power).
Does this problem get better or worse the more reliant the arts are on government support?
How should you connect the individual artist’s loss to the loss experienced by society as a whole?
T - 0
T - 0
Liftoff!
Liftoff!
Topic Sentence
Arts should not rely on government support due to the increased tendency of ideological conformity to the agendas of the government or even censorship — at the expense of the political autonomy so central to the arts.
Topic Sentence
Arts should not rely on government support due to the increased tendency of ideological conformity to the agendas of the government or even censorship — at the expense of the political autonomy so central to the arts.
Topic Sentence
Arts should not rely on government support due to the increased tendency of ideological conformity to the agendas of the government or even censorship — at the expense of the political autonomy so central to the arts.
Framework: Appearance vs. Reality
Since the arts may risk maintaining an appearance of being neutral and universal, while in reality serving the needs of those in power.
Framework: Appearance vs. Reality
Since the arts may risk maintaining an appearance of being neutral and universal, while in reality serving the needs of those in power.
Framework: Appearance vs. Reality
Since the arts may risk maintaining an appearance of being neutral and universal, while in reality serving the needs of those in power.
The provision of federal support inevitably entails some form of reciprocity on the part of the artist, who may be compelled to deliberately stifle narratives or perspectives which their works have sought to channel should they run counter to the agendas of the patron,
in which case retribution (the withdrawal of funding, for instance) may swiftly ensue and consequently threaten the lifeline such artisans depend upon.
Yet, this runs antithetical to the very purpose of the arts — to hold an unflinching, unfiltered view of the complexities and truths of reality, regardless of whether they are palatable to authority.
Example I. The ‘American Sublime’ Exhibition (2025). Prominent Black artist Amy Sherald announced she was cancelling her exhibition at the Smithsonian Museum, American Sublime, after receiving news that the Trump administration had explicitly ordered the Smithsonian to bar “improper” perspectives from display — a reference to her transgender take on the Statue of Liberty in her magnum opus.
Notably, this event was to be the first large-scale exhibition by a Black artist, yet it ended in shambles at the hands of an institution which receives more than half its funding from federal sources — consequently succumbing to political pressure to stifle artistic freedoms.
Note the correspondence between our arguments and the details of the example: 1) what was censored? 2) what was the reason for censorship? 3) where is the evidence that the artist/institution was ‘controlled’ by the government? all three points, which we talk about in our argument, are answered by the info we present in our example. This is what we mean by the correspondence rule.
Example II. The UK Royal Exchange Theatre (2025): A modern take of Shakespeare’s A Midsummer’s Night Dream — and at one of the most esteemed national theatres — was hastily retracted due to alleged concerns raised by a government official on its references to the Israel-Palestine war & transgender rights.
Example III. In Singapore, artists like Alfian Sa’at have often received official notices at the 11th hour to modify the content in their manuscripts and seen their plays suspended until the required changes have been made. Meanwhile, writers like Sonny Liew — author of The Art of Charlie Chan Hock Chye, which presents an alternative history of Singapore’s founding years — were met with the revoking of their publication grants after refusing to comply.
Government support, it seems, fosters a greater proclivity towards the self-policing or even the voluntary excising of narratives;
Worse, the more evident the benefits of state provisions are for the sector, the greater the extent to which such authoritative leverage over artists is amplified.
And as sections of the human condition become cordoned off to align with the interests of authority, the arts may lose their authenticity and become less a universal and empowering mode of human expression than a mouthpiece for those in power.
When our culture is pervaded by state-controlled and state-regulated art forms, this in turn may indoctrinate citizens into mistaking the socio-political ideas depicted through art for natural and unquestionable truths — which would be disastrous for not just freedom of expression, but the diversity and plurality of thought integral to a healthy and robust society.
The provision of federal support inevitably entails some form of reciprocity on the part of the artist, who may be compelled to deliberately stifle narratives or perspectives which their works have sought to channel should they run counter to the agendas of the patron,
in which case retribution (the withdrawal of funding, for instance) may swiftly ensue and consequently threaten the lifeline such artisans depend upon.
Yet, this runs antithetical to the very purpose of the arts — to hold an unflinching, unfiltered view of the complexities and truths of reality, regardless of whether they are palatable to authority.
Example I. The ‘American Sublime’ Exhibition (2025). Prominent Black artist Amy Sherald announced she was cancelling her exhibition at the Smithsonian Museum, American Sublime, after receiving news that the Trump administration had explicitly ordered the Smithsonian to bar “improper” perspectives from display — a reference to her transgender take on the Statue of Liberty in her magnum opus.
Notably, this event was to be the first large-scale exhibition by a Black artist, yet it ended in shambles at the hands of an institution which receives more than half its funding from federal sources — consequently succumbing to political pressure to stifle artistic freedoms.
Note the correspondence between our arguments and the details of the example: 1) what was censored? 2) what was the reason for censorship? 3) where is the evidence that the artist/institution was ‘controlled’ by the government? all three points, which we talk about in our argument, are answered by the info we present in our example. This is what we mean by the correspondence rule.
Example II. The UK Royal Exchange Theatre (2025): A modern take of Shakespeare’s A Midsummer’s Night Dream — and at one of the most esteemed national theatres — was hastily retracted due to alleged concerns raised by a government official on its references to the Israel-Palestine war & transgender rights.
Example III. In Singapore, artists like Alfian Sa’at have often received official notices at the 11th hour to modify the content in their manuscripts and seen their plays suspended until the required changes have been made. Meanwhile, writers like Sonny Liew — author of The Art of Charlie Chan Hock Chye, which presents an alternative history of Singapore’s founding years — were met with the revoking of their publication grants after refusing to comply.
Government support, it seems, fosters a greater proclivity towards the self-policing or even the voluntary excising of narratives;
Worse, the more evident the benefits of state provisions are for the sector, the greater the extent to which such authoritative leverage over artists is amplified.
And as sections of the human condition become cordoned off to align with the interests of authority, the arts may lose their authenticity and become less a universal and empowering mode of human expression than a mouthpiece for those in power.
When our culture is pervaded by state-controlled and state-regulated art forms, this in turn may indoctrinate citizens into mistaking the socio-political ideas depicted through art for natural and unquestionable truths — which would be disastrous for not just freedom of expression, but the diversity and plurality of thought integral to a healthy and robust society.
The provision of federal support inevitably entails some form of reciprocity on the part of the artist, who may be compelled to deliberately stifle narratives or perspectives which their works have sought to channel should they run counter to the agendas of the patron,
in which case retribution (the withdrawal of funding, for instance) may swiftly ensue and consequently threaten the lifeline such artisans depend upon.
Yet, this runs antithetical to the very purpose of the arts — to hold an unflinching, unfiltered view of the complexities and truths of reality, regardless of whether they are palatable to authority.
Example I. The ‘American Sublime’ Exhibition (2025). Prominent Black artist Amy Sherald announced she was cancelling her exhibition at the Smithsonian Museum, American Sublime, after receiving news that the Trump administration had explicitly ordered the Smithsonian to bar “improper” perspectives from display — a reference to her transgender take on the Statue of Liberty in her magnum opus.
Notably, this event was to be the first large-scale exhibition by a Black artist, yet it ended in shambles at the hands of an institution which receives more than half its funding from federal sources — consequently succumbing to political pressure to stifle artistic freedoms.
Note the correspondence between our arguments and the details of the example: 1) what was censored? 2) what was the reason for censorship? 3) where is the evidence that the artist/institution was ‘controlled’ by the government? all three points, which we talk about in our argument, are answered by the info we present in our example. This is what we mean by the correspondence rule.
Example II. The UK Royal Exchange Theatre (2025): A modern take of Shakespeare’s A Midsummer’s Night Dream — and at one of the most esteemed national theatres — was hastily retracted due to alleged concerns raised by a government official on its references to the Israel-Palestine war & transgender rights.
Example III. In Singapore, artists like Alfian Sa’at have often received official notices at the 11th hour to modify the content in their manuscripts and seen their plays suspended until the required changes have been made. Meanwhile, writers like Sonny Liew — author of The Art of Charlie Chan Hock Chye, which presents an alternative history of Singapore’s founding years — were met with the revoking of their publication grants after refusing to comply.
Government support, it seems, fosters a greater proclivity towards the self-policing or even the voluntary excising of narratives;
Worse, the more evident the benefits of state provisions are for the sector, the greater the extent to which such authoritative leverage over artists is amplified.
And as sections of the human condition become cordoned off to align with the interests of authority, the arts may lose their authenticity and become less a universal and empowering mode of human expression than a mouthpiece for those in power.
When our culture is pervaded by state-controlled and state-regulated art forms, this in turn may indoctrinate citizens into mistaking the socio-political ideas depicted through art for natural and unquestionable truths — which would be disastrous for not just freedom of expression, but the diversity and plurality of thought integral to a healthy and robust society.
Thesis 3
Thesis 3
Thesis 3
Hide Mental Exercise
Mental Exercise For Thesis 3
Mental Exercise For Thesis 3
Mental Exercise For Thesis 3
T - 4
T - 4
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
Suppose the state is willing and the money exists. What still stands between the money and the artist? Is the problem the amount of funding, or the process?
To spend public money fairly, what must a government do (measure, compare, justify)? What does that in turn demand of art — and can art provide that in the first place?
If a system built to support art ends up producing less of it, what framework is that?
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
Suppose the state is willing and the money exists. What still stands between the money and the artist? Is the problem the amount of funding, or the process?
To spend public money fairly, what must a government do (measure, compare, justify)? What does that in turn demand of art — and can art provide that in the first place?
If a system built to support art ends up producing less of it, what framework is that?
T - 3
T - 3
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
Why must governments measure — and what is it about the value of art that resists measurement? What is the paradox here?
What happens to a new or unknown artist under popularity-based metrics (ticket sales, viewership)? Can they prove significance before they’ve reached an audience — and can they reach an audience before they’ve proved significance?
Why are governments structurally slow even when nothing goes wrong? Think about chains of dependency: whose decision waits on whose?
Compatibility: name the qualities of art and the qualities of administration. Are they reconcilable, or is there an inevitable conflict that arises?
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
Why must governments measure — and what is it about the value of art that resists measurement? What is the paradox here?
What happens to a new or unknown artist under popularity-based metrics (ticket sales, viewership)? Can they prove significance before they’ve reached an audience — and can they reach an audience before they’ve proved significance?
Why are governments structurally slow even when nothing goes wrong? Think about chains of dependency: whose decision waits on whose?
Compatibility: name the qualities of art and the qualities of administration. Are they reconcilable, or is there an inevitable conflict that arises?
T - 2
T - 2
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
Think of a country globally admired for efficient governance that nonetheless burdens its artists with paperwork and KPIs. Use the “even” technique: if bureaucracy stifles art even there, what does this mean for other countries?
Recall a recent case where a national funding body kept many organisations waiting for months because it couldn’t confirm its own budget, or in general a case where the application or funding process was incredibly time-consuming, complex, or convoluted.
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
Think of a country globally admired for efficient governance that nonetheless burdens its artists with paperwork and KPIs. Use the “even” technique: if bureaucracy stifles art even there, what does this mean for other countries?
Recall a recent case where a national funding body kept many organisations waiting for months because it couldn’t confirm its own budget, or in general a case where the application or funding process was incredibly time-consuming, complex, or convoluted.
T - 1
T - 1
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
Which group or type of artists are most vulnerable to bureaucracy? Is it well-known ones?
Link delay to consequence explicitly: a theatre cannot sign a contract on a grant it has not yet been given. What else can’t happen while the decision is pending?
Connect the KPI example to the paradox: how does a metric designed to reward artists with greater reach prevent them from ever gaining that?
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
Which group or type of artists are most vulnerable to bureaucracy? Is it well-known ones?
Link delay to consequence explicitly: a theatre cannot sign a contract on a grant it has not yet been given. What else can’t happen while the decision is pending?
Connect the KPI example to the paradox: how does a metric designed to reward artists with greater reach prevent them from ever gaining that?
T - 0
T - 0
Liftoff!
Liftoff!
Topic Sentence
Finally, art should not depend on government support due to the imposition of bureaucratic or procedural hurdles which would hinder the propagation and flourishing of the arts.
Topic Sentence
Finally, art should not depend on government support due to the imposition of bureaucratic or procedural hurdles which would hinder the propagation and flourishing of the arts.
Topic Sentence
Finally, art should not depend on government support due to the imposition of bureaucratic or procedural hurdles which would hinder the propagation and flourishing of the arts.
Framework: Irony / Paradox
Government support is intended to help the arts flourish, but the bureaucratic processes it involves ends up going against that goal.
Framework: Irony / Paradox
Government support is intended to help the arts flourish, but the bureaucratic processes it involves ends up going against that goal.
This is the case even in countries historically recognised for their efficiency in governance [again, recall the aforementioned technique with “even..”] :
Example I. Singapore’s Art KPIs: Despite the government’s devotion to expand and diversify the local aesthetic landscape, Singapore’s arts scene today remains weighed down by excessive bureaucratic hurdles. To receive funding for their works, artists are forced to comply with cumbersome paperwork and abide by stringent Key Performance Indicators (KPI) such as ticket sales and viewership.
As a result, budding local artists have expressed frustration and helplessness that their creative ambitions have been stifled by the very regulations intended to amplify them.
*Notice how throughout the essay, examples are embedded with explanations and elaborations that link to the “self-interest” keyword, whether explicitly or not.
In fact, the significance of a work of art — particularly those created by new or lesser known artists — may not be evident before it gains access to a wider demographic, but it is also barred from doing so before it gains demonstrable popularity.
This entraps countless artists and artworks in cycle of anonymity, possibly discouraging them from further pursuing their artistic ambitions and preventing their works (current or future) from receiving a chance to be appreciated by the wider populace.
Example II. Scotland Creative’s Funding Delay (2025). In Scotland, 281 arts institutions across the nation spent the autumn of 2024 unable to plan a single event because the government could not confirm its overall budget, and thus the proportion allocated to the creative sector, until its December statement was released. This delay sparked a further wave of complaints regarding the funding application process itself, which took up to 1.5 years and involved requirements that were both complex and convoluted.
We can see how there exists an inevitable paradox in endowing art with government support: finite national budgets necessitate the creation of a universal, objective metric by which to determine the allocation of state support to artists, yet the true value of art is subjective and evades quantification.
Even in the absence of unforeseeable disruptions, chains of dependency coupled with strict adherence to procedures compound the time lags and delays which frequently occur in branches of government — prolonging the uncertainty for artists and organisations, and consequently preventing them from definitively committing to their work.
Therefore, state support may not be compatible with the arts given that the inherent qualities of the discipline itself — defined by irregularities and subjective plurality — resists the political architecture designed for governance.
This is the case even in countries historically recognised for their efficiency in governance [again, recall the aforementioned technique with “even..”] :
Example I. Singapore’s Art KPIs: Despite the government’s devotion to expand and diversify the local aesthetic landscape, Singapore’s arts scene today remains weighed down by excessive bureaucratic hurdles. To receive funding for their works, artists are forced to comply with cumbersome paperwork and abide by stringent Key Performance Indicators (KPI) such as ticket sales and viewership.
As a result, budding local artists have expressed frustration and helplessness that their creative ambitions have been stifled by the very regulations intended to amplify them.
*Notice how throughout the essay, examples are embedded with explanations and elaborations that link to the “self-interest” keyword, whether explicitly or not.
In fact, the significance of a work of art — particularly those created by new or lesser known artists — may not be evident before it gains access to a wider demographic, but it is also barred from doing so before it gains demonstrable popularity.
This entraps countless artists and artworks in cycle of anonymity, possibly discouraging them from further pursuing their artistic ambitions and preventing their works (current or future) from receiving a chance to be appreciated by the wider populace.
Example II. Scotland Creative’s Funding Delay (2025). In Scotland, 281 arts institutions across the nation spent the autumn of 2024 unable to plan a single event because the government could not confirm its overall budget, and thus the proportion allocated to the creative sector, until its December statement was released. This delay sparked a further wave of complaints regarding the funding application process itself, which took up to 1.5 years and involved requirements that were both complex and convoluted.
We can see how there exists an inevitable paradox in endowing art with government support: finite national budgets necessitate the creation of a universal, objective metric by which to determine the allocation of state support to artists, yet the true value of art is subjective and evades quantification.
Even in the absence of unforeseeable disruptions, chains of dependency coupled with strict adherence to procedures compound the time lags and delays which frequently occur in branches of government — prolonging the uncertainty for artists and organisations, and consequently preventing them from definitively committing to their work.
Therefore, state support may not be compatible with the arts given that the inherent qualities of the discipline itself — defined by irregularities and subjective plurality — resists the political architecture designed for governance.
This is the case even in countries historically recognised for their efficiency in governance [again, recall the aforementioned technique with “even..”] :
Example I. Singapore’s Art KPIs: Despite the government’s devotion to expand and diversify the local aesthetic landscape, Singapore’s arts scene today remains weighed down by excessive bureaucratic hurdles. To receive funding for their works, artists are forced to comply with cumbersome paperwork and abide by stringent Key Performance Indicators (KPI) such as ticket sales and viewership.
As a result, budding local artists have expressed frustration and helplessness that their creative ambitions have been stifled by the very regulations intended to amplify them.
*Notice how throughout the essay, examples are embedded with explanations and elaborations that link to the “self-interest” keyword, whether explicitly or not.
In fact, the significance of a work of art — particularly those created by new or lesser known artists — may not be evident before it gains access to a wider demographic, but it is also barred from doing so before it gains demonstrable popularity.
This entraps countless artists and artworks in cycle of anonymity, possibly discouraging them from further pursuing their artistic ambitions and preventing their works (current or future) from receiving a chance to be appreciated by the wider populace.
Example II. Scotland Creative’s Funding Delay (2025). In Scotland, 281 arts institutions across the nation spent the autumn of 2024 unable to plan a single event because the government could not confirm its overall budget, and thus the proportion allocated to the creative sector, until its December statement was released. This delay sparked a further wave of complaints regarding the funding application process itself, which took up to 1.5 years and involved requirements that were both complex and convoluted.
We can see how there exists an inevitable paradox in endowing art with government support: finite national budgets necessitate the creation of a universal, objective metric by which to determine the allocation of state support to artists, yet the true value of art is subjective and evades quantification.
Even in the absence of unforeseeable disruptions, chains of dependency coupled with strict adherence to procedures compound the time lags and delays which frequently occur in branches of government — prolonging the uncertainty for artists and organisations, and consequently preventing them from definitively committing to their work.
Therefore, state support may not be compatible with the arts given that the inherent qualities of the discipline itself — defined by irregularities and subjective plurality — resists the political architecture designed for governance.
In A Nutshell
In A Nutshell
In A Nutshell
That concludes our discussion on this essay question! Again, quite a lot of content, but there's no need at all to use everything — take away what aligns with you! Finally, a quick summary of the key recurring insights throughout this essay:
As with all sectors that are do not offer goods and services essential to citizens' lives, there is a good argument for why art requires the support of an authority: not just because of the funding and publicity (to allow the industry to not just survive, but thrive), but also the stability associated with the government — which is unlikely to suddenly go bankrupt, nor retract budget decisions already made — which allows the arts to mitigate even times of huge volatility.
On the other hand, one of the biggest concerns against state support is that dependence and leverage, or control, are two sides of the same coin. Relying on someone for survival also implies that they can also control or command what you do in exchange, even if these are simply "requests", since you are always indebted to them and know they can choose to abandon you at any time. This is actually the same insight we cover in Issue 6 of the Newsletter, on the US-Iran war!
That's it for today — see you in the next piece :)
That concludes our discussion on this essay question! Again, quite a lot of content, but there's no need at all to use everything — take away what aligns with you! Finally, a quick summary of the key recurring insights throughout this essay:
As with all sectors that are do not offer goods and services essential to citizens' lives, there is a good argument for why art requires the support of an authority: not just because of the funding and publicity (to allow the industry to not just survive, but thrive), but also the stability associated with the government — which is unlikely to suddenly go bankrupt, nor retract budget decisions already made — which allows the arts to mitigate even times of huge volatility.
On the other hand, one of the biggest concerns against state support is that dependence and leverage, or control, are two sides of the same coin. Relying on someone for survival also implies that they can also control or command what you do in exchange, even if these are simply "requests", since you are always indebted to them and know they can choose to abandon you at any time. This is actually the same insight we cover in Issue 6 of the Newsletter, on the US-Iran war!
That's it for today — see you in the next piece :)
That concludes our discussion on this essay question! Again, quite a lot of content, but there's no need at all to use everything — take away what aligns with you! Finally, a quick summary of the key recurring insights throughout this essay:
As with all sectors that are do not offer goods and services essential to citizens' lives, there is a good argument for why art requires the support of an authority: not just because of the funding and publicity (to allow the industry to not just survive, but thrive), but also the stability associated with the government — which is unlikely to suddenly go bankrupt, nor retract budget decisions already made — which allows the arts to mitigate even times of huge volatility.
On the other hand, one of the biggest concerns against state support is that dependence and leverage, or control, are two sides of the same coin. Relying on someone for survival also implies that they can also control or command what you do in exchange, even if these are simply "requests", since you are always indebted to them and know they can choose to abandon you at any time. This is actually the same insight we cover in Issue 6 of the Newsletter, on the US-Iran war!
That's it for today — see you in the next piece :)



