
Essays
Essays
Examiner Report I
Examiner Report I
Examiner Report 1
The Politics of Cooperation
The Politics of Cooperation
Is the pursuit of self-interest always bad?
Is the pursuit of self-interest always bad?
Oct 15, 2026
Oct 15, 2026
(ASRJC 2025 Prelims)
In an increasingly volatile world, is the pursuit of self-interest always bad?
The following content is only available to Deluxe subscribers.
Make an upgrade today.
Get Deluxe →
Deluxe
$18.60/m
A Step Above
All features within the Premium Track at your fingertips
Full access to all Essays.
Starter Kit — detailed cheat sheet to help you ace all components of the essay, released in stages.
Priority access to new services, including the Essay Studio.
Deluxe
A Step Above
$16.50/m $18.60
All features in the Premium Track.
Full access to all Essays.
Full Starter Kit — to help you ace all components of the essay, released in stages.
Priority access to new services, including the Essay Studio.
General Notes
General Notes
General Notes
On "well-developed" Examples
You do not need to use all the examples accompanying each point — often, 2 well-developed ones are enough in a paragraph (along with their corresponding evaluations).
"Well-developed" means you don’t just give a one-line summary of the example, for instance, like “Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022 shows that…”, and jump straight into evaluation.
Two reliable ways you can develop any example: 1) answer the why? behind the event, and 2) provide details showing how your example illustrates the point you’re making.
Using point 1 (For) as an example: the argument you’re trying to make is that pursuing self-interest causes excessive harm. The example we’re using is DOGE/Elon Musk’s removal of US foreign aid programmes.
Why did Musk do it? → he believed these initiatives were wasteful and self-destructive to the country.
What details do we need to show how this example causes excessive harm? → foreign aid originally provided relief to countless victims of civil unrest/genocide in countries like Sudan and Syria. Now, millions more deaths are expected to result from the removal of this aid.
You’ve just reconstructed the entire well-developed example you see below.
Consider the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), which, stewarded by billionaire Elon Musk, had taken a literal chainsaw to US foreign aid initiatives (USAID), including those supplying humanitarian aid for countries like Sudan and Syria embroiled in civil unrest/genocide — in a purging of what he saw as wasteful, outdated notions of altruism bestowed on disadvantaged nations. That withdrawal, conducted in the name of national self-interest, is now projected to cause millions more preventable deaths by 2030.
On "well-developed" Examples
You do not need to use all the examples accompanying each point — often, 2 well-developed ones are enough in a paragraph (along with their corresponding evaluations).
"Well-developed" means you don’t just give a one-line summary of the example, for instance, like “Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022 shows that…”, and jump straight into evaluation.
Two reliable ways you can develop any example: 1) answer the why? behind the event, and 2) provide details showing how your example illustrates the point you’re making.
Using point 1 (For) as an example: the argument you’re trying to make is that pursuing self-interest causes excessive harm. The example we’re using is DOGE/Elon Musk’s removal of US foreign aid programmes.
Why did Musk do it? → he believed these initiatives were wasteful and self-destructive to the country.
What details do we need to show how this example causes excessive harm? → foreign aid originally provided relief to countless victims of civil unrest/genocide in countries like Sudan and Syria. Now, millions more deaths are expected to result from the removal of this aid.
You’ve just reconstructed the entire well-developed example you see below.
Consider the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), which, stewarded by billionaire Elon Musk, had taken a literal chainsaw to US foreign aid initiatives (USAID), including those supplying humanitarian aid for countries like Sudan and Syria embroiled in civil unrest/genocide — in a purging of what he saw as wasteful, outdated notions of altruism bestowed on disadvantaged nations. That withdrawal, conducted in the name of national self-interest, is now projected to cause millions more preventable deaths by 2030.
On "well-developed" Examples
You do not need to use all the examples accompanying each point — often, 2 well-developed ones are enough in a paragraph (along with their corresponding evaluations).
"Well-developed" means you don’t just give a one-line summary of the example, for instance, like “Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022 shows that…”, and jump straight into evaluation.
Two reliable ways you can develop any example: 1) answer the why? behind the event, and 2) provide details showing how your example illustrates the point you’re making.
Using point 1 (For) as an example: the argument you’re trying to make is that pursuing self-interest causes excessive harm. The example we’re using is DOGE/Elon Musk’s removal of US foreign aid programmes.
Why did Musk do it? → he believed these initiatives were wasteful and self-destructive to the country.
What details do we need to show how this example causes excessive harm? → foreign aid originally provided relief to countless victims of civil unrest/genocide in countries like Sudan and Syria. Now, millions more deaths are expected to result from the removal of this aid.
You’ve just reconstructed the entire well-developed example you see below.
Consider the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), which, stewarded by billionaire Elon Musk, had taken a literal chainsaw to US foreign aid initiatives (USAID), including those supplying humanitarian aid for countries like Sudan and Syria embroiled in civil unrest/genocide — in a purging of what he saw as wasteful, outdated notions of altruism bestowed on disadvantaged nations. That withdrawal, conducted in the name of national self-interest, is now projected to cause millions more preventable deaths by 2030.
II. How You can Practice Using This Report
Reading through this page is going to be decently helpful, but you stand to gain so much more. Here's the mental exercise we recommend if you want to practice thinking yourself before we reveal the answers:
Mental Exercise For Each Body Paragraph / Thesis
In the style of a rocket launch
II. How You can Practice Using This Report
Reading through this page is going to be decently helpful, but you stand to gain so much more. Here's the mental exercise we recommend if you want to practice thinking yourself before we reveal the answers:
Mental Exercise For Each Body Paragraph / Thesis
In the style of a rocket launch
II. How You can Practice Using This Report
Reading through this page is going to be decently helpful, but you stand to gain so much more. Here's the mental exercise we recommend if you want to practice thinking yourself before we reveal the answers:
Mental Exercise For Each Body Paragraph / Thesis
In the style of a rocket launch
T - 4
T - 4
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
The most common ones are 1) appearance vs reality, 2) paradox, 3) irony and 4) layering — often, these are sufficient for most essays you’ll ever encounter.
Why these frameworks, you may ask? That’s because any one of them will definitely give you more to talk about in your evaluation and accompanying explanation/elaborations.
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
The most common ones are 1) appearance vs reality, 2) paradox, 3) irony and 4) layering — often, these are sufficient for most essays you’ll ever encounter.
Why these frameworks, you may ask? That’s because any one of them will definitely give you more to talk about in your evaluation and accompanying explanation/elaborations.
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
T - 3
T - 3
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
T - 2
T - 2
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
T - 1
T - 1
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Some guiding questions:
how would you explain / elaborate on each thesis in the leadup to your first example (if necessary)?
how would you explain / elaborate your example to closely link to the question’s keywords, and so the evaluation after comes more naturally?
how would you connect each evaluation to the next example, or the next idea, insight, or claim you want to bring in?
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Some guiding questions:
how would you explain / elaborate on each thesis in the leadup to your first example (if necessary)?
how would you explain / elaborate your example to closely link to the question’s keywords, and so the evaluation after comes more naturally?
how would you connect each evaluation to the next example, or the next idea, insight, or claim you want to bring in?
Hints specific to each thesis will also be given — check out Thesis 1 for a worked example.
T - 0
T - 0
Liftoff!
Liftoff!
Colour Code
Colour Code
Colour Code
We’ve made each paragraph really well-developed for learning purposes. However, this also means they can get a bit long.
As such, we have colour-coded the key parts of the factual examples, the key evaluations, and accompanying explanations/elaborations — these are the ones which we recommend looking at first.
We’ve made each paragraph really well-developed for learning purposes. However, this also means they can get a bit long.
As such, we have colour-coded the key parts of the factual examples, the key evaluations, and accompanying explanations/elaborations — these are the ones which we recommend looking at first.
Example
Factual evidence which supports your argument. However, the Example should not simply be a regurgitation of facts; phrases and keywords that explicitly link back to your thesis are necessary. For that reason, it is often intertwined with Elaboration and Explanation, as we shall see below.
Example
Factual evidence which supports your argument. However, the Example should not simply be a regurgitation of facts; phrases and keywords that explicitly link back to your thesis are necessary. For that reason, it is often intertwined with Elaboration and Explanation, as we shall see below.
Evaluation
Perhaps the most important part of the essay.
Demonstrates your personal judgement on the issue at hand or the idea being discussed.
Discusses the wider implications of your argument — what is at stake? who is affected? what are the consequences to society or the world?
Evaluation
Perhaps the most important part of the essay.
Demonstrates your personal judgement on the issue at hand or the idea being discussed.
Discusses the wider implications of your argument — what is at stake? who is affected? what are the consequences to society or the world?
Evaluation
Perhaps the most important part of the essay.
Demonstrates your personal judgement on the issue at hand or the idea being discussed.
Discusses the wider implications of your argument — what is at stake? who is affected? what are the consequences to society or the world?
Explanation/Elaborations
Explanations provide the justification and reasoning in support of the claim you’re making — answers the "why": “why is this so?” “what makes this convincing/true?” Elaborations develop the argument by pushing it to greater depth (causes, mechanisms), or greater breadth (impacts, implications).
Explanation/Elaborations
Explanations provide the justification and reasoning in support of the claim you’re making — answers the "why": “why is this so?” “what makes this convincing/true?” Elaborations develop the argument by pushing it to greater depth (causes, mechanisms), or greater breadth (impacts, implications).
Explanation/Elaborations
Explanations provide the justification and reasoning in support of the claim you’re making — answers the "why": “why is this so?” “what makes this convincing/true?” Elaborations develop the argument by pushing it to greater depth (causes, mechanisms), or greater breadth (impacts, implications).
Key Point
Important remarks we want you to take note of.
Key Point
Important remarks we want you to take note of.
For completeness, we’re going to run through arguments for both Agree and Disagree, and you can try doing a quick mental exercise before we reveal the content pointers for each paragraph — don’t worry, we’ll guide you along.
Let's Go!
For completeness, we’re going to run through arguments for both Agree and Disagree, and you can try doing a quick mental exercise before we reveal the content pointers for each paragraph — don’t worry, we’ll guide you along.
Let's Go!
For completeness, we’re going to run through arguments for both Agree and Disagree, and you can try doing a quick mental exercise before we reveal the content pointers for each paragraph — don’t worry, we’ll guide you along.
Let's Go!
Question Analysis
Question Analysis
Question Analysis
First, which GP domain(s) does this question fall under?
First, which GP domain(s) does this question fall under?
First, which GP domain(s) does this question fall under?
Click to reveal answer
Next, what are the keywords in the question?
In an increasingly volatile world, is the pursuit of self-interest always bad?
Next, what are the keywords in the question?
In an increasingly volatile world, is the pursuit of self-interest always bad?
Next, what are the keywords in the question?
In an increasingly volatile world, is the pursuit of self-interest always bad?
Click to reveal answer
How should we interpret these keywords?
How should we interpret these keywords?
How should we interpret these keywords?
Click to reveal answer
The Hook
The Hook
The Hook
There is no “right” or “wrong” stance in GP — this is, and always will be, true.
However, what many don’t realise is that there sometimes is a stance which grants you more room to develop more complex thoughts, observations and insights; in other words, there can be a stance that's better to aim for high Content marks.
How do we know which is usually the better stance? As with all subjects, GP rewards you for more work and more thought, and so the stance that on first glance seems harder or counterintuitive to support is often the one you should tackle if you can. That said, try to come up with at least 2 topic sentences first before committing; don’t force yourself to argue for a stance you have nothing to say about just because it “can” lead to higher marks.
In this case, both the Agree and Disagree stances are rich in possible discussion — which is the hallmark of a good question!
However, we have made these hook suggestions more suited to the Agree stance for learning purposes, because it seems more counterintuitive that pursuing self-interest is a bad thing in an increasingly volatile world.
[Quote] “Politics has no relation to morals” — Renaissance philosopher Machiavelli
It seemed that separating statecraft from virtue was central to proper, pragmatic governance — that, in essence, only self-interest should dictate decisions that would affect the fate of a nation.
[Question] Is there anything wrong with ensuring the survival of the self when even that certainty seems to be slipping from our grasp?
This is the very predicament that countless face today, and for whom the choice between pursuing and forgoing self-interest is an illusive binary, given that all becomes meaningless if the fundamental survival or continuity of the self is threatened.
[Example] You can also summarise any one of the examples we use throughout the examiner’s report — each of them have been carefully picked such that they would also make thought-provoking hooks.
Possible explanation/elaboration you can add
Today, in an increasingly volatile global landscape rife with conflict, uncertainty and looming environmental crises, securing domestic interests before all else — even if that means forfeiting international ties and obligations — appears more compelling than ever.
In this case, your explanation/elaboration accompanying the hook must explicitly address the context of the question — "in an increasingly volatile world" — because it is given.
There is no “right” or “wrong” stance in GP — this is, and always will be, true.
However, what many don’t realise is that there sometimes is a stance which grants you more room to develop more complex thoughts, observations and insights; in other words, there can be a stance that's better to aim for high Content marks.
How do we know which is usually the better stance? As with all subjects, GP rewards you for more work and more thought, and so the stance that on first glance seems harder or counterintuitive to support is often the one you should tackle if you can. That said, try to come up with at least 2 topic sentences first before committing; don’t force yourself to argue for a stance you have nothing to say about just because it “can” lead to higher marks.
In this case, both the Agree and Disagree stances are rich in possible discussion — which is the hallmark of a good question!
However, we have made these hook suggestions more suited to the Agree stance for learning purposes, because it seems more counterintuitive that pursuing self-interest is a bad thing in an increasingly volatile world.
[Quote] “Politics has no relation to morals” — Renaissance philosopher Machiavelli
It seemed that separating statecraft from virtue was central to proper, pragmatic governance — that, in essence, only self-interest should dictate decisions that would affect the fate of a nation.
[Question] Is there anything wrong with ensuring the survival of the self when even that certainty seems to be slipping from our grasp?
This is the very predicament that countless face today, and for whom the choice between pursuing and forgoing self-interest is an illusive binary, given that all becomes meaningless if the fundamental survival or continuity of the self is threatened.
[Example] You can also summarise any one of the examples we use throughout the examiner’s report — each of them have been carefully picked such that they would also make thought-provoking hooks.
Possible explanation/elaboration you can add
Today, in an increasingly volatile global landscape rife with conflict, uncertainty and looming environmental crises, securing domestic interests before all else — even if that means forfeiting international ties and obligations — appears more compelling than ever.
In this case, your explanation/elaboration accompanying the hook must explicitly address the context of the question — "in an increasingly volatile world" — because it is given.
Thesis 1
Thesis 1
Thesis 1
Hide Mental Exercise
Mental Exercise For Thesis 1 (worked example)
Mental Exercise For Thesis 1 (worked example)
Mental Exercise For Thesis 1 (worked example)
T - 4
T - 4
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
In my first thesis I want to argue something along the lines of, the pursuit of self-interest is bad because it might end up backfiring (and not being good for self-interest at all). This uses the framework of a paradox.
Hints
Given that the question is global in scope, whose self-interest would it make more sense to talk about in our first thesis? That of nations and countries.
How can one's pursuit of self-interest backfire? There are actually two possibilities: the more obvious one being that you do something that you didn't realise is bad for yourself, and the other one being that you affect others in a bad way, which ends up coming back to bite you.
Don't forget to include the Context about volatility in your topic sentence, since the question explicitly states it! Based on our question analysis, it might also be helpful to decide on one particular aspect of volatility you wish to discuss. In this case, I want to focus on geopolitical volatility (conflict, war etc) since this domain is the easiest to show how something done in self-interest can backfire.
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
In my first thesis I want to argue something along the lines of, the pursuit of self-interest is bad because it might end up backfiring (and not being good for self-interest at all). This uses the framework of a paradox.
Hints
Given that the question is global in scope, whose self-interest would it make more sense to talk about in our first thesis? That of nations and countries.
How can one's pursuit of self-interest backfire? There are actually two possibilities: the more obvious one being that you do something that you didn't realise is bad for yourself, and the other one being that you affect others in a bad way, which ends up coming back to bite you.
Don't forget to include the Context about volatility in your topic sentence, since the question explicitly states it! Based on our question analysis, it might also be helpful to decide on one particular aspect of volatility you wish to discuss. In this case, I want to focus on geopolitical volatility (conflict, war etc) since this domain is the easiest to show how something done in self-interest can backfire.
T - 3
T - 3
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Self-interested countries are susceptible to a kind of myopia as they neglect possible long-term consequences, or things whose value cannot be quantified, in their decision-making and only grasp what is certain.
In the context of conflict or war, hostilities tend to be self-perpetuating (i.e. creating an endless loop), like how a war only provokes another war and another in response. Hence countries end up devoting more and more resources to sustain the act of self-interest, which becomes a sunk cost fallacy.
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Self-interested countries are susceptible to a kind of myopia as they neglect possible long-term consequences, or things whose value cannot be quantified, in their decision-making and only grasp what is certain.
In the context of conflict or war, hostilities tend to be self-perpetuating (i.e. creating an endless loop), like how a war only provokes another war and another in response. Hence countries end up devoting more and more resources to sustain the act of self-interest, which becomes a sunk cost fallacy.
T - 2
T - 2
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them. Some well-known examples I can think of are 1) US scrapping their foreign aid programmes, 2) the back and forth of the US-Iran or Russia-Ukraine war, 3) the rearming of France and Germany after the US withdrew key military commitments towards its allies in Europe
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
For the US-Iran / Russia-Ukraine example, I realise that I can draw more insights: 1) volatility compels leaders to downplay abstract, long-term estimations and instead prioritise immediate, geopolitical gains -> hence they initiate conflict, 2) they also cannot withdraw from conflict easily to be accountable to the electorate, or to uphold their own image (think Putin promising Russians in 2022 that victory will come in months).
Now that I have the France & Germany rearming example, I realise there's another observation: each nation, seeing others buildup their military, will try to build theirs up too, so we have a kind of vicious spiral that ends up leaving everyone more vulnerable and worse off in "self-interest".
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them. Some well-known examples I can think of are 1) US scrapping their foreign aid programmes, 2) the back and forth of the US-Iran or Russia-Ukraine war, 3) the rearming of France and Germany after the US withdrew key military commitments towards its allies in Europe
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
For the US-Iran / Russia-Ukraine example, I realise that I can draw more insights: 1) volatility compels leaders to downplay abstract, long-term estimations and instead prioritise immediate, geopolitical gains -> hence they initiate conflict, 2) they also cannot withdraw from conflict easily to be accountable to the electorate, or to uphold their own image (think Putin promising Russians in 2022 that victory will come in months).
Now that I have the France & Germany rearming example, I realise there's another observation: each nation, seeing others buildup their military, will try to build theirs up too, so we have a kind of vicious spiral that ends up leaving everyone more vulnerable and worse off in "self-interest".
T - 1
T - 1
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Eg. To connect the USAID cuts example to the eval point on myopia, I can first talk about how, beyond whether the staggering humanitarian cost of lives could ever be justified with budget savings, the move effectively voided America’s stature on the global stage, as a moral compass and trustworthy leader — yet these implications are left out of the arithmetic because it's impossible to assign a value to them.
Eg. To connect the France & Germany rearming example to the eval point on a vicious spiral, I can first talk about how in isolation, each state’s defensive buildup is, externally, indistinguishable from offensive preparations — so actually prompts other nations to bolster their own armaments out of security concerns. Ultimately, everyone thus becomes more vulnerable because there's now so much more firepower in deployment, plus there's been a huge drainage of resources poured into military expenditure.
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Eg. To connect the USAID cuts example to the eval point on myopia, I can first talk about how, beyond whether the staggering humanitarian cost of lives could ever be justified with budget savings, the move effectively voided America’s stature on the global stage, as a moral compass and trustworthy leader — yet these implications are left out of the arithmetic because it's impossible to assign a value to them.
Eg. To connect the France & Germany rearming example to the eval point on a vicious spiral, I can first talk about how in isolation, each state’s defensive buildup is, externally, indistinguishable from offensive preparations — so actually prompts other nations to bolster their own armaments out of security concerns. Ultimately, everyone thus becomes more vulnerable because there's now so much more firepower in deployment, plus there's been a huge drainage of resources poured into military expenditure.
T - 0
T - 0
Liftoff!
Topic Sentence
In a world increasingly stricken with geopolitical tensions and fractured by conflict, countries’ fixation on self-interest can result in excessive harm inflicted on both external and, paradoxically, domestic stakeholders — especially given that such pursuits tend to be self-perpetuating.
Topic Sentence
In a world increasingly stricken with geopolitical tensions and fractured by conflict, countries’ fixation on self-interest can result in excessive harm inflicted on both external and, paradoxically, domestic stakeholders — especially given that such pursuits tend to be self-perpetuating.
Topic Sentence
In a world increasingly stricken with geopolitical tensions and fractured by conflict, countries’ fixation on self-interest can result in excessive harm inflicted on both external and, paradoxically, domestic stakeholders — especially given that such pursuits tend to be self-perpetuating.
Framework: Paradox
Pursuing "self-interest" and inflicting harm upon yourself seem to be completely contradictory goals; yet the former leads to the latter.
Framework: Paradox
Pursuing "self-interest" and inflicting harm upon yourself seem to be completely contradictory goals; yet the former leads to the latter.
Framework: Paradox
Pursuing "self-interest" and inflicting harm upon yourself seem to be completely contradictory goals; yet the former leads to the latter.
Example: The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), stewarded by billionaire Elon Musk who, brandishing a chainsaw on stage as his emblem, gutted US foreign initiatives (USAID) in countries like Sudan, Syria and parts of Africa plagued by famine, civil unrest and disease — in a purging of what he saw as wasteful, outdated notions of altruism bestowed on disadvantaged nations. That withdrawal, conducted in the name of national self-interest, is now projected to cause millions more preventable deaths by 2030.
Yet USAID funds the very networks which detected outbreaks like Ebola and bird flu before they reached American soil. And beyond whether the staggering humanitarian cost of lives could ever be justified with budget savings, the move effectively voided America’s stature on the global stage, as a moral compass and trustworthy leader.
This means that by being preoccupied with the arithmetic calculus of self-interest, countries inadvertently end up dismantling the very international apparatus, as well as its strategic or reputational influence on the global stage, which are integral to domestic prosperity — yet cannot be assigned a numerical value. At the same time, this breeds a kind of strategic myopia whereby countries grasp only at immediate certainties without factoring in the long-term implications of a decision, which similarly evade quantification. This almost certainly undermines the same self-interest which was so prized to begin with.
This is a good starting point as it illustrates that harm does not necessarily require action to manifest; sometimes, inaction is more than enough.
Worse, the pursuit of self-interest can lose its chance to terminate and thus resultant hostilities can become dangerously self-perpetuating.
Example: You can cite the ongoing US-Iran war which has lasted well beyond the “5 weeks” initially assured by Trump, and in which negotiations have reached what seems like a permanent impasse. Yet his apparent hubris has in fact been an unrelenting pursuit of self-interest: an abhorrence towards all compromise in talks with Iran despite being aware of the nation’s reputation as a hardline and unrelenting negotiator, and perhaps more notably, recent renewals of aggression targeting Iranian infrastructure in hopes of extracting concessions, but which have only invited retaliatory bombardments — spreading destruction across Israel and the Middle East.
Key Point: elab/exp in examples are either generalisable so as to make a broad and convincing claim, rather than a narrow one (which the reader may interpret as “only working in specific contexts”), OR provide a clear link to the keywords (in this case, “pursuit of self-interest”)
Another equally compelling example is Putin’s relentless onslaught on Ukraine which, four years on, still has no end in sight — even with the Kremlin forcibly conscripting Russian citizens to replenish its depleting forces. The devastating human toll that has accumulated on both sides of the warzone attests to Russia’s refusal to extricate itself from a war intended to stave off NATO presence on its doorstep, and initiated because defeat had seemed an impossibility.
Underpinning all of this is that volatility and uncertainty narrows the horizons within which national decisions are made; that compels leaders to downplay abstract, long-term projections and instead prioritise the immediacy of geopolitical gains.
Yet at the same time, withdrawal is also precisely what such pursuits forbid, given the considerable sunk cost already devoted to the cause — implying that it is often difficult for invested nations to jettison existing progress, whether to uphold political image or accountability to the electorate. (a kind of sunk cost fallacy!)
In turn, nations can find themselves entrapped in a compulsive cycle of devoting increasing resources to cling on to foreseen benefits when hindrances to attaining them inevitably arise. What may thus eventually appear as political brinkmanship or reckless decision-making are often natural consequences of chasing self-interest.
In fact, pursuing self-interest encourages or even emboldens other nations to do the same.
Recently, France and Germany have re-armed following the United States’ retreat into self-interest by withdrawing key military commitments towards its allies in Europe; defence spending in the EU has also reached historic highs.
In isolation, each state’s military buildup — given that defensive reinforcements are, externally, indistinguishable from offensive preparations — actually prompts other nations to bolster their own armaments out of security concerns.
This can rapidly devolve into a vicious spiral of competition, in which every nation attempts to match its neighbour’s investment and each, having sought only self-preservation, ironically ends up more exposed to the very arsenals its own vigilance provoked. (this is also known as the security dilemma in international relations, a very fascinating concept.) In other words, fighting with a zero-sum view of the world can ironically land one deeper in a lose-lose deadlock.
Therefore, the pursuit of self-serving objectives can in many ways be self-defeating: by worsening harm irrevocably inflicted on domestic and external stakeholders, which ultimately — and rather ironically — comes at the expense of the state’s own self-interest.
Note the personal judgement shown here through words like “ironically” and “self-defeating” — this is also a form of eval!
Example: The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), stewarded by billionaire Elon Musk who, brandishing a chainsaw on stage as his emblem, gutted US foreign initiatives (USAID) in countries like Sudan, Syria and parts of Africa plagued by famine, civil unrest and disease — in a purging of what he saw as wasteful, outdated notions of altruism bestowed on disadvantaged nations. That withdrawal, conducted in the name of national self-interest, is now projected to cause millions more preventable deaths by 2030.
Yet USAID funds the very networks which detected outbreaks like Ebola and bird flu before they reached American soil. And beyond whether the staggering humanitarian cost of lives could ever be justified with budget savings, the move effectively voided America’s stature on the global stage, as a moral compass and trustworthy leader.
This means that by being preoccupied with the arithmetic calculus of self-interest, countries inadvertently end up dismantling the very international apparatus, as well as its strategic or reputational influence on the global stage, which are integral to domestic prosperity — yet cannot be assigned a numerical value. At the same time, this breeds a kind of strategic myopia whereby countries grasp only at immediate certainties without factoring in the long-term implications of a decision, which similarly evade quantification. This almost certainly undermines the same self-interest which was so prized to begin with.
This is a good starting point as it illustrates that harm does not necessarily require action to manifest; sometimes, inaction is more than enough.
Worse, the pursuit of self-interest can lose its chance to terminate and thus resultant hostilities can become dangerously self-perpetuating.
Example: You can cite the ongoing US-Iran war which has lasted well beyond the “5 weeks” initially assured by Trump, and in which negotiations have reached what seems like a permanent impasse. Yet his apparent hubris has in fact been an unrelenting pursuit of self-interest: an abhorrence towards all compromise in talks with Iran despite being aware of the nation’s reputation as a hardline and unrelenting negotiator, and perhaps more notably, recent renewals of aggression targeting Iranian infrastructure in hopes of extracting concessions, but which have only invited retaliatory bombardments — spreading destruction across Israel and the Middle East.
Key Point: elab/exp in examples are either generalisable so as to make a broad and convincing claim, rather than a narrow one (which the reader may interpret as “only working in specific contexts”), OR provide a clear link to the keywords (in this case, “pursuit of self-interest”)
Another equally compelling example is Putin’s relentless onslaught on Ukraine which, four years on, still has no end in sight — even with the Kremlin forcibly conscripting Russian citizens to replenish its depleting forces. The devastating human toll that has accumulated on both sides of the warzone attests to Russia’s refusal to extricate itself from a war intended to stave off NATO presence on its doorstep, and initiated because defeat had seemed an impossibility.
Underpinning all of this is that volatility and uncertainty narrows the horizons within which national decisions are made; that compels leaders to downplay abstract, long-term projections and instead prioritise the immediacy of geopolitical gains.
Yet at the same time, withdrawal is also precisely what such pursuits forbid, given the considerable sunk cost already devoted to the cause — implying that it is often difficult for invested nations to jettison existing progress, whether to uphold political image or accountability to the electorate. (a kind of sunk cost fallacy!)
In turn, nations can find themselves entrapped in a compulsive cycle of devoting increasing resources to cling on to foreseen benefits when hindrances to attaining them inevitably arise. What may thus eventually appear as political brinkmanship or reckless decision-making are often natural consequences of chasing self-interest.
In fact, pursuing self-interest encourages or even emboldens other nations to do the same.
Recently, France and Germany have re-armed following the United States’ retreat into self-interest by withdrawing key military commitments towards its allies in Europe; defence spending in the EU has also reached historic highs.
In isolation, each state’s military buildup — given that defensive reinforcements are, externally, indistinguishable from offensive preparations — actually prompts other nations to bolster their own armaments out of security concerns.
This can rapidly devolve into a vicious spiral of competition, in which every nation attempts to match its neighbour’s investment and each, having sought only self-preservation, ironically ends up more exposed to the very arsenals its own vigilance provoked. (this is also known as the security dilemma in international relations, a very fascinating concept.) In other words, fighting with a zero-sum view of the world can ironically land one deeper in a lose-lose deadlock.
Therefore, the pursuit of self-serving objectives can in many ways be self-defeating: by worsening harm irrevocably inflicted on domestic and external stakeholders, which ultimately — and rather ironically — comes at the expense of the state’s own self-interest.
Note the personal judgement shown here through words like “ironically” and “self-defeating” — this is also a form of eval!
Example: The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), stewarded by billionaire Elon Musk who, brandishing a chainsaw on stage as his emblem, gutted US foreign initiatives (USAID) in countries like Sudan, Syria and parts of Africa plagued by famine, civil unrest and disease — in a purging of what he saw as wasteful, outdated notions of altruism bestowed on disadvantaged nations. That withdrawal, conducted in the name of national self-interest, is now projected to cause millions more preventable deaths by 2030.
Yet USAID funds the very networks which detected outbreaks like Ebola and bird flu before they reached American soil. And beyond whether the staggering humanitarian cost of lives could ever be justified with budget savings, the move effectively voided America’s stature on the global stage, as a moral compass and trustworthy leader.
This means that by being preoccupied with the arithmetic calculus of self-interest, countries inadvertently end up dismantling the very international apparatus, as well as its strategic or reputational influence on the global stage, which are integral to domestic prosperity — yet cannot be assigned a numerical value. At the same time, this breeds a kind of strategic myopia whereby countries grasp only at immediate certainties without factoring in the long-term implications of a decision, which similarly evade quantification. This almost certainly undermines the same self-interest which was so prized to begin with.
This is a good starting point as it illustrates that harm does not necessarily require action to manifest; sometimes, inaction is more than enough.
Worse, the pursuit of self-interest can lose its chance to terminate and thus resultant hostilities can become dangerously self-perpetuating.
Example: You can cite the ongoing US-Iran war which has lasted well beyond the “5 weeks” initially assured by Trump, and in which negotiations have reached what seems like a permanent impasse. Yet his apparent hubris has in fact been an unrelenting pursuit of self-interest: an abhorrence towards all compromise in talks with Iran despite being aware of the nation’s reputation as a hardline and unrelenting negotiator, and perhaps more notably, recent renewals of aggression targeting Iranian infrastructure in hopes of extracting concessions, but which have only invited retaliatory bombardments — spreading destruction across Israel and the Middle East.
Key Point: elab/exp in examples are either generalisable so as to make a broad and convincing claim, rather than a narrow one (which the reader may interpret as “only working in specific contexts”), OR provide a clear link to the keywords (in this case, “pursuit of self-interest”)
Another equally compelling example is Putin’s relentless onslaught on Ukraine which, four years on, still has no end in sight — even with the Kremlin forcibly conscripting Russian citizens to replenish its depleting forces. The devastating human toll that has accumulated on both sides of the warzone attests to Russia’s refusal to extricate itself from a war intended to stave off NATO presence on its doorstep, and initiated because defeat had seemed an impossibility.
Underpinning all of this is that volatility and uncertainty narrows the horizons within which national decisions are made; that compels leaders to downplay abstract, long-term projections and instead prioritise the immediacy of geopolitical gains.
Yet at the same time, withdrawal is also precisely what such pursuits forbid, given the considerable sunk cost already devoted to the cause — implying that it is often difficult for invested nations to jettison existing progress, whether to uphold political image or accountability to the electorate. (a kind of sunk cost fallacy!)
In turn, nations can find themselves entrapped in a compulsive cycle of devoting increasing resources to cling on to foreseen benefits when hindrances to attaining them inevitably arise. What may thus eventually appear as political brinkmanship or reckless decision-making are often natural consequences of chasing self-interest.
In fact, pursuing self-interest encourages or even emboldens other nations to do the same.
Recently, France and Germany have re-armed following the United States’ retreat into self-interest by withdrawing key military commitments towards its allies in Europe; defence spending in the EU has also reached historic highs.
In isolation, each state’s military buildup — given that defensive reinforcements are, externally, indistinguishable from offensive preparations — actually prompts other nations to bolster their own armaments out of security concerns.
This can rapidly devolve into a vicious spiral of competition, in which every nation attempts to match its neighbour’s investment and each, having sought only self-preservation, ironically ends up more exposed to the very arsenals its own vigilance provoked. (this is also known as the security dilemma in international relations, a very fascinating concept.) In other words, fighting with a zero-sum view of the world can ironically land one deeper in a lose-lose deadlock.
Therefore, the pursuit of self-serving objectives can in many ways be self-defeating: by worsening harm irrevocably inflicted on domestic and external stakeholders, which ultimately — and rather ironically — comes at the expense of the state’s own self-interest.
Note the personal judgement shown here through words like “ironically” and “self-defeating” — this is also a form of eval!
Thesis 2
Thesis 2
Thesis 2
Hide Mental Exercise
Mental Exercise For Thesis 2
Mental Exercise For Thesis 2
Mental Exercise For Thesis 2
T - 4
T - 4
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
People pursue self-interest to improve their lives. From another perspective, the pursuit of self-interest reduces the number of problems they have. This begs the question: what could make the pursuit of self-interest a bad or ineffective choice? Or rather, what do we associate with the opposite of self-interest?
Recall that this entire question takes place on the global scale. After we covered geopolitical volatility in Thesis 1, which aspect of volatility do you think would be suitable to bring in given this global context?
Clearly volatility and unpredictability is something that nations don't like. In view of (a) and (b), do you think continuing to pursue self-interest result in less or more volatility?
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
People pursue self-interest to improve their lives. From another perspective, the pursuit of self-interest reduces the number of problems they have. This begs the question: what could make the pursuit of self-interest a bad or ineffective choice? Or rather, what do we associate with the opposite of self-interest?
Recall that this entire question takes place on the global scale. After we covered geopolitical volatility in Thesis 1, which aspect of volatility do you think would be suitable to bring in given this global context?
Clearly volatility and unpredictability is something that nations don't like. In view of (a) and (b), do you think continuing to pursue self-interest result in less or more volatility?
T - 3
T - 3
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
You've probably guessed from T-4 that there are some global problems one country cannot solve by itself. What happens when a country decides to withdraw from a global effort out of self-interest? Does the impact change depending on what this country is?
Why do some problems absolutely require everybody's cooperation? Are there any qualities of the modern age that result in this? Think about the major global crises we've faced or are facing.
If global issues technically affect everyone, why do some countries still not contribute? (think short vs. long run, and more importantly, is everyone affected equally?)
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
You've probably guessed from T-4 that there are some global problems one country cannot solve by itself. What happens when a country decides to withdraw from a global effort out of self-interest? Does the impact change depending on what this country is?
Why do some problems absolutely require everybody's cooperation? Are there any qualities of the modern age that result in this? Think about the major global crises we've faced or are facing.
If global issues technically affect everyone, why do some countries still not contribute? (think short vs. long run, and more importantly, is everyone affected equally?)
T - 2
T - 2
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
Which country recently withdrew from the Paris climate agreement?
What was one of Trump's motives behind starting the US-Iran war and what global problem does that point to? (clue: nuclear)
(a) points at an environmental crisis, (b) at a man-made crisis. What about a well-known biological crisis? How did countries express self-interest during that crisis?
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
Which country recently withdrew from the Paris climate agreement?
What was one of Trump's motives behind starting the US-Iran war and what global problem does that point to? (clue: nuclear)
(a) points at an environmental crisis, (b) at a man-made crisis. What about a well-known biological crisis? How did countries express self-interest during that crisis?
T - 1
T - 1
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
Is there any way to punish countries who withdraw from global agreements (e.g. the climate agreement), and why? What are these agreements built on?
For the countries pursuing self-interest during global crises, why did they deem it necessary to do so?
Why did these self-interested countries not gain as much as they wanted to, or even suffered in the end? You can go back to the nature of a global crisis in T-3, or the characteristic of the world today which leads to that result.
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
Is there any way to punish countries who withdraw from global agreements (e.g. the climate agreement), and why? What are these agreements built on?
For the countries pursuing self-interest during global crises, why did they deem it necessary to do so?
Why did these self-interested countries not gain as much as they wanted to, or even suffered in the end? You can go back to the nature of a global crisis in T-3, or the characteristic of the world today which leads to that result.
T - 0
T - 0
Liftoff!
Liftoff!
Topic Sentence
Pursuing self-interest fosters an insularity that undercuts the international cooperation and solidarity required to tackle intractable global issues brought about by an increasingly unpredictable world, which worsens the very volatility and threats from which nations sought to distance themselves from.
Topic Sentence
Pursuing self-interest fosters an insularity that undercuts the international cooperation and solidarity required to tackle intractable global issues brought about by an increasingly unpredictable world, which worsens the very volatility and threats from which nations sought to distance themselves from.
Framework: Irony/Paradox
Pursuing "self-interest" may lead to international problems becoming unresolved or even worse, which ends up creating more chaos and danger.
Framework: Irony/Paradox
Pursuing "self-interest" may lead to international problems becoming unresolved or even worse, which ends up creating more chaos and danger.
Framework: Irony/Paradox
Pursuing "self-interest" may lead to international problems becoming unresolved or even worse, which ends up creating more chaos and danger.
Just this year, the US withdrew from the Paris Agreement citing “economic damage” and “unfair burdens”, leaving a vacuum where it had historically been the diplomatic leader in the global fight against climate change.
You can discuss the corrosion of reciprocal trust, premised upon foregrounding the greater good over self-interest, which tackling global crises like climate change requires, and which the entire agreement depends on — given the lack of concrete mechanisms to enforce cooperation.
Such collaborative frameworks have been rendered increasingly tenuous/fragile in light of the stark precedent set by nations withdrawing out of self-interest, particularly if the nation is responsible for establishing the consensus underpinning global collaboration in the first place.
In turn, this could very well vindicate the negligence of smaller nations seeking to reap individual gains by evading obligations or desisting collaboration. Needless to say, such decisions undertaken purely for private gain inevitably dampens the morale and momentum of concerted international efforts aimed at addressing crises which ultimately implicate all of humanity.
If you’ve been following the US-Iran war, you can also raise the nuclear settlement which both countries reached in 2015 — the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) — to ensure Iran’s nuclear program would not attain weapon-grade capability. But the JCPOA was thrown out the window along with other de-escalation frameworks under Trump’s administration, which was unsatisfied with what America stood to gain when its might could seemingly provide greater leverage. That has now left negotiations on the verge of a complete breakdown. The fate of Iran’s nuclear stockpile remain unanswered; its retaliatory strikes under US pressure have only dragged the world further into chaos.
Perhaps nowhere are such unilateralist tendencies more evident* than during the global vaccine scramble amidst the COVID-19 pandemic, where countries such as India froze vaccine exports when the Delta wave struck to prioritise domestic recovery. Yet the abysmal vaccination rates in low-income regions soon catalysed the emergence of the Omicron strand in Africa which then swept across the globe, including the very countries whose stockpiles supposedly warranted their safety.
Despite being grounded in pragmatism, retrospection clearly shows that the hoarding of key resources could not anticipate nor withstand uncertainty of global crises, but also the interconnectedness of economies in a globalised era where even one party’s act of desisting collaboration could undercut an entire international framework.
Systemic failure on a broader, global scale is often not the result of distortions arising from malice or greed, but the cumulative effect of decisions which, individually, are perfectly reasonable justifications for self-interest.
*Again, this is a good way of showing judgement.
Adhering to self-interest also risks becoming a form of tunnel vision (similar to the concept of myopia we mentioned previously), particularly when the impacts of volatile global crises are geographically asymmetric. Nations who are relatively insulated or distanced from such shocks consequently perceive little impetus to act, and default to apathy. Yet, challenges like climate change or even nuclear proliferation, unprecedented in both scale and magnitude, will ultimately spell disaster for all if not structurally addressed and contained via concerted global efforts.
Take the Tuvalu protocol for example: proposed jointly by an alliance of small, low-lying island nations and calling for the imposition of more ambitious emission targets to curtail the trajectory of rising sea levels. Yet their proposal was immediately shot down at the climate summit by the coalition of China, India and Saudi Arabia — some of the world’s largest emitters, but for whom climate change had no foreseeable bearing on national survival.
Just this year, the US withdrew from the Paris Agreement citing “economic damage” and “unfair burdens”, leaving a vacuum where it had historically been the diplomatic leader in the global fight against climate change.
You can discuss the corrosion of reciprocal trust, premised upon foregrounding the greater good over self-interest, which tackling global crises like climate change requires, and which the entire agreement depends on — given the lack of concrete mechanisms to enforce cooperation.
Such collaborative frameworks have been rendered increasingly tenuous/fragile in light of the stark precedent set by nations withdrawing out of self-interest, particularly if the nation is responsible for establishing the consensus underpinning global collaboration in the first place.
In turn, this could very well vindicate the negligence of smaller nations seeking to reap individual gains by evading obligations or desisting collaboration. Needless to say, such decisions undertaken purely for private gain inevitably dampens the morale and momentum of concerted international efforts aimed at addressing crises which ultimately implicate all of humanity.
If you’ve been following the US-Iran war, you can also raise the nuclear settlement which both countries reached in 2015 — the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) — to ensure Iran’s nuclear program would not attain weapon-grade capability. But the JCPOA was thrown out the window along with other de-escalation frameworks under Trump’s administration, which was unsatisfied with what America stood to gain when its might could seemingly provide greater leverage. That has now left negotiations on the verge of a complete breakdown. The fate of Iran’s nuclear stockpile remain unanswered; its retaliatory strikes under US pressure have only dragged the world further into chaos.
Perhaps nowhere are such unilateralist tendencies more evident* than during the global vaccine scramble amidst the COVID-19 pandemic, where countries such as India froze vaccine exports when the Delta wave struck to prioritise domestic recovery. Yet the abysmal vaccination rates in low-income regions soon catalysed the emergence of the Omicron strand in Africa which then swept across the globe, including the very countries whose stockpiles supposedly warranted their safety.
Despite being grounded in pragmatism, retrospection clearly shows that the hoarding of key resources could not anticipate nor withstand uncertainty of global crises, but also the interconnectedness of economies in a globalised era where even one party’s act of desisting collaboration could undercut an entire international framework.
Systemic failure on a broader, global scale is often not the result of distortions arising from malice or greed, but the cumulative effect of decisions which, individually, are perfectly reasonable justifications for self-interest.
*Again, this is a good way of showing judgement.
Adhering to self-interest also risks becoming a form of tunnel vision (similar to the concept of myopia we mentioned previously), particularly when the impacts of volatile global crises are geographically asymmetric. Nations who are relatively insulated or distanced from such shocks consequently perceive little impetus to act, and default to apathy. Yet, challenges like climate change or even nuclear proliferation, unprecedented in both scale and magnitude, will ultimately spell disaster for all if not structurally addressed and contained via concerted global efforts.
Take the Tuvalu protocol for example: proposed jointly by an alliance of small, low-lying island nations and calling for the imposition of more ambitious emission targets to curtail the trajectory of rising sea levels. Yet their proposal was immediately shot down at the climate summit by the coalition of China, India and Saudi Arabia — some of the world’s largest emitters, but for whom climate change had no foreseeable bearing on national survival.
Thesis 3
Thesis 3
Thesis 3
Hide Mental Exercise
Mental Exercise For Thesis 3
Mental Exercise For Thesis 3
Mental Exercise For Thesis 3
T - 4
T - 4
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
Imagine you are a citizen of country X. How would you actually know if something is done in the best interests of your country? Who conveys that information to you? Do they also have their self-interests?
As you probably can guess, politicians also have their own self-interests which sometimes replace a nation's. But if you were a politician, would you make it very obvious that you're pursuing your own interests? What kind of defence or cover would you give yourself — thus, what can we then say about the portrayal of national interest?
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
Imagine you are a citizen of country X. How would you actually know if something is done in the best interests of your country? Who conveys that information to you? Do they also have their self-interests?
As you probably can guess, politicians also have their own self-interests which sometimes replace a nation's. But if you were a politician, would you make it very obvious that you're pursuing your own interests? What kind of defence or cover would you give yourself — thus, what can we then say about the portrayal of national interest?
T - 3
T - 3
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
What are the costs and consequences when politicians pursue their own self-interest? Clue: which aspects of domestic welfare are possibly sacrificed?
Part of good governance is listening to and addressing the needs of the people; moreover, the rule of leaders depends on popular support, at least in democratic nations. What can we say about the morality of governance when authorities pursue their own self-interest?
What can politicians use or take advantage of in order to 1) get citizens to support their cause, and 2) conceal their true motives from citizens? Clue: think about some of the concepts we've already seen in the Newsletter: rhetoric, information asymmetry.
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
What are the costs and consequences when politicians pursue their own self-interest? Clue: which aspects of domestic welfare are possibly sacrificed?
Part of good governance is listening to and addressing the needs of the people; moreover, the rule of leaders depends on popular support, at least in democratic nations. What can we say about the morality of governance when authorities pursue their own self-interest?
What can politicians use or take advantage of in order to 1) get citizens to support their cause, and 2) conceal their true motives from citizens? Clue: think about some of the concepts we've already seen in the Newsletter: rhetoric, information asymmetry.
T - 2
T - 2
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
The wave of Gen Z protests across Indonesia, Nepal and the Philippines under the One Piece flag.
What actions have authoritarian rulers (e.g. in Iran, Russia) taken to preserve their own interests or stay in power?
Is Britain still part of the European Union? This is also one of the most famous case studies concerning the dynamic between politicians and people.
What happened when Trump lost the election to Biden in 2021?
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
The wave of Gen Z protests across Indonesia, Nepal and the Philippines under the One Piece flag.
What actions have authoritarian rulers (e.g. in Iran, Russia) taken to preserve their own interests or stay in power?
Is Britain still part of the European Union? This is also one of the most famous case studies concerning the dynamic between politicians and people.
What happened when Trump lost the election to Biden in 2021?
T - 1
T - 1
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
In the examples, why was it in the self-interest of politicians to do what they did?
Why do many citizens unquestioningly accept what politicians tell them? Are there any features of modern day which contribute to this? (hint: how do we receive information?)
Why is it that citizens may still have no way of verifying whether politicians are telling the truth even if they can discern fake news?
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
In the examples, why was it in the self-interest of politicians to do what they did?
Why do many citizens unquestioningly accept what politicians tell them? Are there any features of modern day which contribute to this? (hint: how do we receive information?)
Why is it that citizens may still have no way of verifying whether politicians are telling the truth even if they can discern fake news?
T - 0
T - 0
Liftoff!
Liftoff!
Topic Sentence
The pursuit of self-interest by the people of a nation may also be fallacious because the concept itself is susceptible to appropriation or manipulation by political agents — a tendency that has only been exacerbated in a world with increasing divisons, and the blurring of lines between truth and falsehood.
Topic Sentence
The pursuit of self-interest by the people of a nation may also be fallacious because the concept itself is susceptible to appropriation or manipulation by political agents — a tendency that has only been exacerbated in a world with increasing divisons, and the blurring of lines between truth and falsehood.
Framework: Appearance vs. Reality + LAYERING*
Political agent can hide under an appearance of serving the national interest — but whose interests are they actually serving?
Framework: Appearance vs. Reality + LAYERING*
Political agent can hide under an appearance of serving the national interest — but whose interests are they actually serving?
Framework: Appearance vs. Reality + LAYERING*
Political agent can hide under an appearance of serving the national interest — but whose interests are they actually serving?
It is relatively evident that self-interest is undesirable when it is shaped or dictated by politicians according to their own desires rather than the needs of the country. Possible examples include:
The waves of anti-corruption protests, across Indonesia, Nepal and the Philippines sparked amidst soaring costs of living and widening social inequality.
The Iranian regime’s recent lethal crackdowns on public dissent regarding economic grievances and the stifling of free speech, to maintain its grip on power.
You can point out the staggering human cost — be it negligence, exploitation or the violation of fundamental human rights — when collective welfare is sacrificed to uphold and enrich the interests of authority.
More importantly, the morality of governance is called into question when such authorities disregard the very people they are obligated to serve, and whose support their rule depends upon.
We include this section before diving into the appearance-reality illusion as a form of layering! (recall this framework from the Newsletter). We first show the examiner we’ve considered the most basic case: that politicians are simply serving their own self-interest, before moving on to the case where they appear to serve the nation but still benefit themselves.
A greater problem arises when politicians’ self-serving agendas are advanced under the guise of a nation’s.
Brexit (2016): the fact that Britain gains more overall from the EU than it loses was obscured beneath populist rhetoric and even misinformation. Slants drastically overstating the costs of immigration and healthcare spending under the EU were circulated on social media, and famously displayed on the sides of buses by the ‘Vote Leave’ movement.
Today, polls show that a clear majority of citizens regrets the withdrawal. But for many politicians backing Leave, winning the referendum was their ticket to political advancement at a time when the leadership of their parties were not strongly Eurosceptic (skeptical of the EU).
Also, let’s not forget that 2021 opened with Trump rallying a mob of supporters to storm the Capitol to reclaim what he deemed a “stolen election”. Despite clear evidence that the votes were legitimate, he painted the insurgency as a noble restoration of justice and democratic accountability to a supposedly rigged system. That led to hundreds of casualties, forced Congress to instate an $2 billion emergency security bill, but most notably ended up largely costing America its moral and reputational standing as a model of democracy.
Modern technology has enabled politicians to utilise the speed and reach of digital channels, from X to Trump’s Truth Social app, to appeal to citizens’ political loyalty or rising nationalistic sentiments through rhetoric which may be factually misleading. Many, however, may unquestioningly accept them either due to the sheer pace at which their information environment updates or the credibility naturally associated with authority.
This is only worsened by the deepening divisions along political lines, exemplified by the current polarisation of the right and left in the US, which can make citizens more susceptible to ideological manipulation intended to provoke antagonism.
Then you have Netanyahu, Israel’s prime minister, who has repeatedly delayed his corruption trial by citing classified “security concerns” and state emergencies triggered by the war in Gaza — which he has also prolonged at the expense of countless lives.
Even if citizens are perceptive enough to parse complexities and discern falsehoods, those wielding power can still take advantage of superior or insider knowledge to conceal ulterior motives — intended solely for personal gain — underneath pretexts which citizens have no way of verifying, because they are not privy to classified information (e.g. matters of national security).
In the pursuit of self-interest, leaders and politicians may be emboldened to masquerade as guardians of the national interest to provide cover for their true intentions, while in reality they benefit at the expense of the welfare of domestic or external stakeholders.
It is relatively evident that self-interest is undesirable when it is shaped or dictated by politicians according to their own desires rather than the needs of the country. Possible examples include:
The waves of anti-corruption protests, across Indonesia, Nepal and the Philippines sparked amidst soaring costs of living and widening social inequality.
The Iranian regime’s recent lethal crackdowns on public dissent regarding economic grievances and the stifling of free speech, to maintain its grip on power.
You can point out the staggering human cost — be it negligence, exploitation or the violation of fundamental human rights — when collective welfare is sacrificed to uphold and enrich the interests of authority.
More importantly, the morality of governance is called into question when such authorities disregard the very people they are obligated to serve, and whose support their rule depends upon.
We include this section before diving into the appearance-reality illusion as a form of layering! (recall this framework from the Newsletter). We first show the examiner we’ve considered the most basic case: that politicians are simply serving their own self-interest, before moving on to the case where they appear to serve the nation but still benefit themselves.
A greater problem arises when politicians’ self-serving agendas are advanced under the guise of a nation’s.
Brexit (2016): the fact that Britain gains more overall from the EU than it loses was obscured beneath populist rhetoric and even misinformation. Slants drastically overstating the costs of immigration and healthcare spending under the EU were circulated on social media, and famously displayed on the sides of buses by the ‘Vote Leave’ movement.
Today, polls show that a clear majority of citizens regrets the withdrawal. But for many politicians backing Leave, winning the referendum was their ticket to political advancement at a time when the leadership of their parties were not strongly Eurosceptic (skeptical of the EU).
Also, let’s not forget that 2021 opened with Trump rallying a mob of supporters to storm the Capitol to reclaim what he deemed a “stolen election”. Despite clear evidence that the votes were legitimate, he painted the insurgency as a noble restoration of justice and democratic accountability to a supposedly rigged system. That led to hundreds of casualties, forced Congress to instate an $2 billion emergency security bill, but most notably ended up largely costing America its moral and reputational standing as a model of democracy.
Modern technology has enabled politicians to utilise the speed and reach of digital channels, from X to Trump’s Truth Social app, to appeal to citizens’ political loyalty or rising nationalistic sentiments through rhetoric which may be factually misleading. Many, however, may unquestioningly accept them either due to the sheer pace at which their information environment updates or the credibility naturally associated with authority.
This is only worsened by the deepening divisions along political lines, exemplified by the current polarisation of the right and left in the US, which can make citizens more susceptible to ideological manipulation intended to provoke antagonism.
Then you have Netanyahu, Israel’s prime minister, who has repeatedly delayed his corruption trial by citing classified “security concerns” and state emergencies triggered by the war in Gaza — which he has also prolonged at the expense of countless lives.
Even if citizens are perceptive enough to parse complexities and discern falsehoods, those wielding power can still take advantage of superior or insider knowledge to conceal ulterior motives — intended solely for personal gain — underneath pretexts which citizens have no way of verifying, because they are not privy to classified information (e.g. matters of national security).
In the pursuit of self-interest, leaders and politicians may be emboldened to masquerade as guardians of the national interest to provide cover for their true intentions, while in reality they benefit at the expense of the welfare of domestic or external stakeholders.
The Nonexistent Thesis 4
The Nonexistent Thesis 4
The Nonexistent Thesis 4
Technically, a form of self-interest you can also discuss for the Agree stance is of extremists / radical groups pursuing their own goals around the world, whether it’s to spread religious gospel, radical beliefs or generally amplify their influence. However, we believe arguing “terrorism is bad” is kind of obvious and you can’t really argue otherwise. You also don’t have much room for complexity or development — in other words, it’s hard to differentiate your response from the rest.
As such, we didn’t include a full paragraph on this thesis.
Technically, a form of self-interest you can also discuss for the Agree stance is of extremists / radical groups pursuing their own goals around the world, whether it’s to spread religious gospel, radical beliefs or generally amplify their influence. However, we believe arguing “terrorism is bad” is kind of obvious and you can’t really argue otherwise. You also don’t have much room for complexity or development — in other words, it’s hard to differentiate your response from the rest.
As such, we didn’t include a full paragraph on this thesis.
Technically, a form of self-interest you can also discuss for the Agree stance is of extremists / radical groups pursuing their own goals around the world, whether it’s to spread religious gospel, radical beliefs or generally amplify their influence. However, we believe arguing “terrorism is bad” is kind of obvious and you can’t really argue otherwise. You also don’t have much room for complexity or development — in other words, it’s hard to differentiate your response from the rest.
As such, we didn’t include a full paragraph on this thesis.
A General Hint for the Antitheses
Before you start brainstorming the 3 topic sentences for the Disagree stance, a small hint is that there’s actually a small trap here: automatically equating “pursuit of self-interest” with “not caring about the interests of others.” That’s not exactly wrong, and tends to be true most of the time, but it limits our thinking — and thus the arguments that we can come up with.
As we will see later, these two actually aren’t mutually exclusive, and the key to coming up with nuanced arguments is to recognise that.
A General Hint for the Antitheses
Before you start brainstorming the 3 topic sentences for the Disagree stance, a small hint is that there’s actually a small trap here: automatically equating “pursuit of self-interest” with “not caring about the interests of others.” That’s not exactly wrong, and tends to be true most of the time, but it limits our thinking — and thus the arguments that we can come up with.
As we will see later, these two actually aren’t mutually exclusive, and the key to coming up with nuanced arguments is to recognise that.
A General Hint for the Antitheses
Before you start brainstorming the 3 topic sentences for the Disagree stance, a small hint is that there’s actually a small trap here: automatically equating “pursuit of self-interest” with “not caring about the interests of others.” That’s not exactly wrong, and tends to be true most of the time, but it limits our thinking — and thus the arguments that we can come up with.
As we will see later, these two actually aren’t mutually exclusive, and the key to coming up with nuanced arguments is to recognise that.
Antithesis 1
Antithesis 1
Antithesis 1
Hide Mental Exercise
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 1
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 1
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 1
T - 4
T - 4
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
What is the most fundamental scenario you can think of where self-interest is justifiable? Or from another angle, what is self-interest taken to the extreme?
There is more than one aspect of volatility that can lead to this same scenario: geopolitical, as well as environmental.
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
What is the most fundamental scenario you can think of where self-interest is justifiable? Or from another angle, what is self-interest taken to the extreme?
There is more than one aspect of volatility that can lead to this same scenario: geopolitical, as well as environmental.
T - 3
T - 3
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
What can we say about ensuring the basic continuity OR sovereignty of a nation in relation to all other obligations? By extension, what can we say about acts of retaliation as a form of self-interest?
Must a nation's actions to ensure these qualities be purely reactive, i.e. done in response to something that's already happened, or can they also be preventive in nature?
(if you want to use this as a counterargument to rebut) Is it easy to draw the line between "necessary" and "beneficial"? Which dangerous outcome could this possibly result in when nations fail to draw this line properly? Clue: we've covered this in one of our 3 Theses.
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
What can we say about ensuring the basic continuity OR sovereignty of a nation in relation to all other obligations? By extension, what can we say about acts of retaliation as a form of self-interest?
Must a nation's actions to ensure these qualities be purely reactive, i.e. done in response to something that's already happened, or can they also be preventive in nature?
(if you want to use this as a counterargument to rebut) Is it easy to draw the line between "necessary" and "beneficial"? Which dangerous outcome could this possibly result in when nations fail to draw this line properly? Clue: we've covered this in one of our 3 Theses.
T - 2
T - 2
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
The Tuvalu Protocol is a useful example here, proposed by island nations in view of rising sea levels which directly threatens their survival.
Iran's retaliation against US aggression in the recent war
What has Singapore done to reduce resource dependence on other nations?
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
The Tuvalu Protocol is a useful example here, proposed by island nations in view of rising sea levels which directly threatens their survival.
Iran's retaliation against US aggression in the recent war
What has Singapore done to reduce resource dependence on other nations?
T - 1
T - 1
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
Which nations are rendered most susceptible to potentially existential threats?
Given the context of an increasingly volatile world, does this context contribute to countries increasingly turning to preventive, rather than reactive, acts of self-interest? If yes, how so? Clue: unpredictability.
Can we argue that Iran's retaliation against the US is a justified one? Clue: what has the US done in its attacks that is controversial?
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
Which nations are rendered most susceptible to potentially existential threats?
Given the context of an increasingly volatile world, does this context contribute to countries increasingly turning to preventive, rather than reactive, acts of self-interest? If yes, how so? Clue: unpredictability.
Can we argue that Iran's retaliation against the US is a justified one? Clue: what has the US done in its attacks that is controversial?
T - 0
T - 0
Liftoff!
Liftoff!
Topic Sentence
The pursuit of self-interest is unassailable / cannot be faulted if it is undertaken to ensure national survival or maintain basic sovereignty.
Topic Sentence
The pursuit of self-interest is unassailable / cannot be faulted if it is undertaken to ensure national survival or maintain basic sovereignty.
Topic Sentence
The pursuit of self-interest is unassailable / cannot be faulted if it is undertaken to ensure national survival or maintain basic sovereignty.
Framework: Layering
As we will see, by the type of volatility.
Framework: Layering
As we will see, by the type of volatility.
Framework: Layering
As we will see, by the type of volatility.
Today, the heightened volatility arising from global crises has rendered smaller and weaker nations more susceptible than ever to existential threats. In this view, ensuring a nation’s continuity is of utmost priority, and an imperative act of self-interest which should temporarily override all other obligations.
The Tuvalu Protocol can be used again as an example here: the stricter emission targets advanced by Tuvalu on behalf of low-lying island countries, though definitely done in self-interest, is entirely justifiable — rising sea levels induced by global warming, if not suppressed in time, would very much be lethal to these nations due to their unique geographical vulnerability.
The same principle also applies to victims of geopolitical or militant aggression, who are forced to defend against threats or infringements on their sovereignty — in which case self-preservation certainly becomes a necessity.
Consider Iran’s recent blockade of the Strait of Hormuz and multiple bombardments in the Middle East. Setting aside the question of proportionality, the regime arguably cannot be faulted for choosing to retaliate in the first place, given strikes by the US directed at civilian infrastructure required to maintain basic societal function — including power plants, roads and water facilities — and when its president threatens to bomb the country “back to the Stone Age”.
In fact, there is an example closer to home: Singapore’s decades-long pursuit of water self-sufficiency. NEWater, desalination, and the Marina Barrage infrastructure all represent sustained and immense expenditure so as to reduce external dependence — upon Malaysia’s water supply — even though it was never actually cut.
An unpredictable or tumultuous global climate makes it almost impossible for a country to anticipate when or how the next disaster will befall its people. Hence devoting resources towards preventive measures, rather than just reactive ones, are also increasingly necessary manifestations of self-interest to provide sufficient insulation from external shocks — which may otherwise jeopardise its survival or, at the very least, cost far more in the aftermath.
A possible rebuttal here if you want to use point 1 as a counterexample: it can be exceedingly hard to draw the line where self-interest out of necessity ends — and perhaps even as to what counts as a necessity. A country can claim they feel threatened and thus launch a “pre-emptive” offensive, or start a “war to end all future wars” with a particular country in the name of neutralising a dangerous threat. And we’ve seen how that turned out.
…and this is actually Thesis 1 (For): that these pursuits risk being self-perpetuating, precisely because misjudging or overstepping the line invites retaliation (which easily provokes a never-ending cycle of revenge). The Israel-Palestine war may be a helpful example: the most recent war was actually started by Palestine, but Israel chose a major escalation that caused a deadly war, especially for Palestinians, that continues today. And guess what Israel used as justification? Yep, self-defence.
Today, the heightened volatility arising from global crises has rendered smaller and weaker nations more susceptible than ever to existential threats. In this view, ensuring a nation’s continuity is of utmost priority, and an imperative act of self-interest which should temporarily override all other obligations.
The Tuvalu Protocol can be used again as an example here: the stricter emission targets advanced by Tuvalu on behalf of low-lying island countries, though definitely done in self-interest, is entirely justifiable — rising sea levels induced by global warming, if not suppressed in time, would very much be lethal to these nations due to their unique geographical vulnerability.
The same principle also applies to victims of geopolitical or militant aggression, who are forced to defend against threats or infringements on their sovereignty — in which case self-preservation certainly becomes a necessity.
Consider Iran’s recent blockade of the Strait of Hormuz and multiple bombardments in the Middle East. Setting aside the question of proportionality, the regime arguably cannot be faulted for choosing to retaliate in the first place, given strikes by the US directed at civilian infrastructure required to maintain basic societal function — including power plants, roads and water facilities — and when its president threatens to bomb the country “back to the Stone Age”.
In fact, there is an example closer to home: Singapore’s decades-long pursuit of water self-sufficiency. NEWater, desalination, and the Marina Barrage infrastructure all represent sustained and immense expenditure so as to reduce external dependence — upon Malaysia’s water supply — even though it was never actually cut.
An unpredictable or tumultuous global climate makes it almost impossible for a country to anticipate when or how the next disaster will befall its people. Hence devoting resources towards preventive measures, rather than just reactive ones, are also increasingly necessary manifestations of self-interest to provide sufficient insulation from external shocks — which may otherwise jeopardise its survival or, at the very least, cost far more in the aftermath.
A possible rebuttal here if you want to use point 1 as a counterexample: it can be exceedingly hard to draw the line where self-interest out of necessity ends — and perhaps even as to what counts as a necessity. A country can claim they feel threatened and thus launch a “pre-emptive” offensive, or start a “war to end all future wars” with a particular country in the name of neutralising a dangerous threat. And we’ve seen how that turned out.
…and this is actually Thesis 1 (For): that these pursuits risk being self-perpetuating, precisely because misjudging or overstepping the line invites retaliation (which easily provokes a never-ending cycle of revenge). The Israel-Palestine war may be a helpful example: the most recent war was actually started by Palestine, but Israel chose a major escalation that caused a deadly war, especially for Palestinians, that continues today. And guess what Israel used as justification? Yep, self-defence.
Antithesis 2
Antithesis 2
Antithesis 2
Hide Mental Exercise
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 2
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 2
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 2
T - 4
T - 4
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
Recall the General Hint we introduced before jumping into the Antitheses. Are self-interest and altruism necessarily incompatible? In other words, can one still serve self-interest by participating in seemingly altruistic acts?
This is also a huge clue as to the type of framework we'll be using.
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
Recall the General Hint we introduced before jumping into the Antitheses. Are self-interest and altruism necessarily incompatible? In other words, can one still serve self-interest by participating in seemingly altruistic acts?
This is also a huge clue as to the type of framework we'll be using.
T - 3
T - 3
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
Consider the opposite of a self-interested act: a selfless act. A selfless act certainly benefits others, but can it ever be separated from a desire or hope, however faint, that you gain something in return?
From another perspective, self-interest can actually be the reason why collaborative frameworks form, kind of like the opposite of Thesis 2 — when countries recognise that there are some beneficial outcomes that can only be achieved together.
What are the ways which member countries can benefit from engaging in collaboration or alliances? Think economic, social/political, and reputational.
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
Consider the opposite of a self-interested act: a selfless act. A selfless act certainly benefits others, but can it ever be separated from a desire or hope, however faint, that you gain something in return?
From another perspective, self-interest can actually be the reason why collaborative frameworks form, kind of like the opposite of Thesis 2 — when countries recognise that there are some beneficial outcomes that can only be achieved together.
What are the ways which member countries can benefit from engaging in collaboration or alliances? Think economic, social/political, and reputational.
T - 2
T - 2
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
Which alliance provided the most support to Ukraine from the very start of the Russian-Ukraine war?
We hinted at previously that small states are most vulnerable to volatility as well as the selfishness of large, powerful countries. Which organisation did Singapore create specifically to tackle this problem?
How can we reuse the US foreign aid example from Thesis 1 but for the opposite argument? Clue: pretend we're going backwards in time — what does the US stand to gain?
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
Which alliance provided the most support to Ukraine from the very start of the Russian-Ukraine war?
We hinted at previously that small states are most vulnerable to volatility as well as the selfishness of large, powerful countries. Which organisation did Singapore create specifically to tackle this problem?
How can we reuse the US foreign aid example from Thesis 1 but for the opposite argument? Clue: pretend we're going backwards in time — what does the US stand to gain?
T - 1
T - 1
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
Which nations are rendered most susceptible to potentially existential threats?
Given the context of an increasingly volatile world, does this context contribute to countries increasingly turning to preventive, rather than reactive, acts of self-interest? If yes, how so? Clue: unpredictability.
One of the justifications Elon Musk gives for removing USAID is that it's a form of "suicidal empathy". But for countries strong enough to not worry about matters of basic survival, what can we actually describe empathy as, in terms of self-interest in the short and long term?
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
Which nations are rendered most susceptible to potentially existential threats?
Given the context of an increasingly volatile world, does this context contribute to countries increasingly turning to preventive, rather than reactive, acts of self-interest? If yes, how so? Clue: unpredictability.
One of the justifications Elon Musk gives for removing USAID is that it's a form of "suicidal empathy". But for countries strong enough to not worry about matters of basic survival, what can we actually describe empathy as, in terms of self-interest in the short and long term?
T - 0
T - 0
Liftoff!
Liftoff!
Topic Sentence
In fact, self-interest can drive acts of cooperation and altruism — built upon the recognition that contributing to the collective cause will ultimately translate into net individual gains.
Topic Sentence
In fact, self-interest can drive acts of cooperation and altruism — built upon the recognition that contributing to the collective cause will ultimately translate into net individual gains.
Topic Sentence
In fact, self-interest can drive acts of cooperation and altruism — built upon the recognition that contributing to the collective cause will ultimately translate into net individual gains.
Framework: Paradox / Appearance vs. Reality
Since we're saying that self-interest can actually coexist with altruism & collaboration — which is both contradictory and surprising.
Framework: Paradox / Appearance vs. Reality
Since we're saying that self-interest can actually coexist with altruism & collaboration — which is both contradictory and surprising.
Framework: Paradox / Appearance vs. Reality
Since we're saying that self-interest can actually coexist with altruism & collaboration — which is both contradictory and surprising.
It may be rather naive to consider that in a world with finite resources and ever-growing unpredictability, all seemingly selfless acts can truly be divested of a desire for reciprocity or the prospect of garnering personal benefits, whether in the short or long term. Conversely, remaining cognisant of self-interest can therefore go a long way in fostering the cooperative structures central to the creation of desirable, productive outcomes at the regional or international level.
A case in point is the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO), a regional alliance founded on a consensus of mutual support and reinforcement; Clause Five of the accord, in particular, equates an attack on one member with an attack on all.
It is this collaborative framework — notably taking precedence over self-interest — which has underpinned allies’ unwavering military and financial aid for Ukraine, for instance, in its defence against Russian aggression.
Simultaneously, all members ultimately benefit from the entailing regional security and stability from neutralising any geopolitical conflict — and crucially the guarantee of reciprocity from its allies should it have to contend with external threats itself.
The Forum of Small States (FOSS), founded by Singapore, meanwhile champions a rules-based international order to uphold stability in an increasingly volatile world. Through dialogues and partnerships, members share their capacities and strategies for conflict prevention as well as peaceful resolution; operating within the UN, FOSS members have also actively pushed back against “might makes right” behaviour which powerful countries like the US, Israel and Russia have gravitated towards.
Yet from a pragmatic standpoint, the element of self-interest remains present because the dismantling of a rules-based order leaves no recourse for small states who simply cannot withstand the military and economic might of global powers.
Furthermore, such multilateral partnerships provide nations with the network and diplomatic infrastructure to identify others sharing a common cause, and thus rally coalition support to push for changes which ultimately benefit them. Fun fact: In 2019, Vanuatu used the FOSS network to rally a coalition of nations, many also small island nations, for an ICJ (International Court of Justice) campaign which led to a landmark ruling that all nations have a clear legal obligation to prevent climate harm — a big reason why many climate laws exist today at all!.
Particularly in an increasingly complex and uncertain world, acts of collaboration or even altruism are often aligned with self-interest, precisely because individual efforts become insufficient to tackle issues on a regional and global scale.
And remember the example of foreign aid and USAID we discussed earlier? Beyond aims of practicality to uphold domestic welfare and stability — for instance, the US bolstering health infrastructure in central Africa during the 2018 Ebola outbreak, to contain its spread towards local soil — what donors actually stand to gain isn’t just in terms of moral reputation at a global level, but also cross-border ties which can lay the foundation for future partnerships and mutual assistance.
Despite concepts along the lines of ‘suicidal empathy’ being used by Musk and the American far-right to justify the dismantling of such initiatives, such critics were implicitly right that, in the realm of politics, empathy is inherently a capacity bestowed on the strong — who possess the choice of forfeiting self-interest in the short term in return for long-term perks.
Therefore, there tends to be a false dichotomy between self-interest and compromise, be it in the form of cooperation or generosity; yet in the grand scheme of things, these are not mutually incompatible pursuits, and can in fact coexist — often, in fact, as derivatives of each other.
It may be rather naive to consider that in a world with finite resources and ever-growing unpredictability, all seemingly selfless acts can truly be divested of a desire for reciprocity or the prospect of garnering personal benefits, whether in the short or long term. Conversely, remaining cognisant of self-interest can therefore go a long way in fostering the cooperative structures central to the creation of desirable, productive outcomes at the regional or international level.
A case in point is the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO), a regional alliance founded on a consensus of mutual support and reinforcement; Clause Five of the accord, in particular, equates an attack on one member with an attack on all.
It is this collaborative framework — notably taking precedence over self-interest — which has underpinned allies’ unwavering military and financial aid for Ukraine, for instance, in its defence against Russian aggression.
Simultaneously, all members ultimately benefit from the entailing regional security and stability from neutralising any geopolitical conflict — and crucially the guarantee of reciprocity from its allies should it have to contend with external threats itself.
The Forum of Small States (FOSS), founded by Singapore, meanwhile champions a rules-based international order to uphold stability in an increasingly volatile world. Through dialogues and partnerships, members share their capacities and strategies for conflict prevention as well as peaceful resolution; operating within the UN, FOSS members have also actively pushed back against “might makes right” behaviour which powerful countries like the US, Israel and Russia have gravitated towards.
Yet from a pragmatic standpoint, the element of self-interest remains present because the dismantling of a rules-based order leaves no recourse for small states who simply cannot withstand the military and economic might of global powers.
Furthermore, such multilateral partnerships provide nations with the network and diplomatic infrastructure to identify others sharing a common cause, and thus rally coalition support to push for changes which ultimately benefit them. Fun fact: In 2019, Vanuatu used the FOSS network to rally a coalition of nations, many also small island nations, for an ICJ (International Court of Justice) campaign which led to a landmark ruling that all nations have a clear legal obligation to prevent climate harm — a big reason why many climate laws exist today at all!.
Particularly in an increasingly complex and uncertain world, acts of collaboration or even altruism are often aligned with self-interest, precisely because individual efforts become insufficient to tackle issues on a regional and global scale.
And remember the example of foreign aid and USAID we discussed earlier? Beyond aims of practicality to uphold domestic welfare and stability — for instance, the US bolstering health infrastructure in central Africa during the 2018 Ebola outbreak, to contain its spread towards local soil — what donors actually stand to gain isn’t just in terms of moral reputation at a global level, but also cross-border ties which can lay the foundation for future partnerships and mutual assistance.
Despite concepts along the lines of ‘suicidal empathy’ being used by Musk and the American far-right to justify the dismantling of such initiatives, such critics were implicitly right that, in the realm of politics, empathy is inherently a capacity bestowed on the strong — who possess the choice of forfeiting self-interest in the short term in return for long-term perks.
Therefore, there tends to be a false dichotomy between self-interest and compromise, be it in the form of cooperation or generosity; yet in the grand scheme of things, these are not mutually incompatible pursuits, and can in fact coexist — often, in fact, as derivatives of each other.
Antithesis 3
Antithesis 3
Antithesis 3
Hide Mental Exercise
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 3
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 3
Mental Exercise For Antithesis 3
T - 4
T - 4
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
We have already covered countries' self-interest and politicians' self-interest pretty thoroughly. Which other category of self-interest have we yet to discuss in detail?
Consider the relationship between the people and the government. What are the main possible scenarios in which the people would want to turn to political expression? (clue: more than 1)
Think of a possible topic sentence you would write to support this current stance — just the key idea will do.
Scribble it down on a piece of paper or in your digital notebook.
What broad framework (remember those in the Newsletter) will you use?
Hints
We have already covered countries' self-interest and politicians' self-interest pretty thoroughly. Which other category of self-interest have we yet to discuss in detail?
Consider the relationship between the people and the government. What are the main possible scenarios in which the people would want to turn to political expression? (clue: more than 1)
T - 3
T - 3
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
The self-interest of one person might be just selfishness. But when many people motivated by self-interest undertake the same thing, what does it show or shed light on?
Think about what could result from a collective pursuit of self-interest through political means. How might this be beneficial, and thus not "bad", for someone in the near future?
One scenario in which people would want to turn to political expression (e.g. protests, movements) is when authorities lack the political will to enact change, which is a more difficult issue. Do you think change is likely to be brought about without the people pursuing self-interest in this way?
Scribble down any evaluation points you already have in mind.
Remember that evaluation is basically you proposing ‘truths’ you want to convince the examiner of: observations, insights, impacts, consequences — basically, what conclusions are you intending to present?
Hints
The self-interest of one person might be just selfishness. But when many people motivated by self-interest undertake the same thing, what does it show or shed light on?
Think about what could result from a collective pursuit of self-interest through political means. How might this be beneficial, and thus not "bad", for someone in the near future?
One scenario in which people would want to turn to political expression (e.g. protests, movements) is when authorities lack the political will to enact change, which is a more difficult issue. Do you think change is likely to be brought about without the people pursuing self-interest in this way?
T - 2
T - 2
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
What was the largest movement against gender inequality in recent years? How did it shed light on a problem which authorities up until then had failed to recognise the severity of?
In general, when you think of protests creating change, what are the most famous, international examples that come to mind?
Back home, protests rarely occur but this makes them all the more valuable. What are some instances of mass protests in Singapore?
Identify 2-3 key examples that you would centre your paragraph around.
If you have already thought of evaluation points for T-2, choose examples that would best illustrate them.
If you haven’t, that’s fine too! Start by penning down examples that come to your mind, preferably well-known ones.
Then for each example, think about what relevant lessons, insights or conclusions can be drawn from them.
Try your best to ensure that different examples don't lead to overlapping insights — otherwise, you'll just be wasting your words.
Hints
What was the largest movement against gender inequality in recent years? How did it shed light on a problem which authorities up until then had failed to recognise the severity of?
In general, when you think of protests creating change, what are the most famous, international examples that come to mind?
Back home, protests rarely occur but this makes them all the more valuable. What are some instances of mass protests in Singapore?
T - 1
T - 1
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
What quality of political movements makes it a powerful catalyst for change?
Imagine you're a citizen living in much uncertainty and unpredictability. How would you feel? Hence, why do you think citizens join social movements and engage in protests? We can actually link this to the broader context that the question tells us. (clue: regaining ___)
Think about how you would add explanations and elaborations for each paragraph.
Remember that it is your evaluations and examples that are the highlight of your paragraph — your explanations & elabs are there simply to hold everything together, acting as kind of logical “bridges” that allow the reader to visualise how you get from A to B as clearly as you can.
Hints
What quality of political movements makes it a powerful catalyst for change?
Imagine you're a citizen living in much uncertainty and unpredictability. How would you feel? Hence, why do you think citizens join social movements and engage in protests? We can actually link this to the broader context that the question tells us. (clue: regaining ___)
T - 0
T - 0
Liftoff!
Liftoff!
Topic Sentence
However, the pursuit of self-interest is not necessarily bad when undertaken by the collective people of a nation; in fact, it is often a necessary catalyst for positive, structural change where authorities lack sufficient political awareness or will.
Topic Sentence
However, the pursuit of self-interest is not necessarily bad when undertaken by the collective people of a nation; in fact, it is often a necessary catalyst for positive, structural change where authorities lack sufficient political awareness or will.
Topic Sentence
However, the pursuit of self-interest is not necessarily bad when undertaken by the collective people of a nation; in fact, it is often a necessary catalyst for positive, structural change where authorities lack sufficient political awareness or will.
Framework: Layering
This time, based on the purposes of political expression / scenarios where it becomes necessary.
Framework: Layering
This time, based on the purposes of political expression / scenarios where it becomes necessary.
Notice how there are two distinct cases we are addressing here: 1) when authorities are not aware of the seriousness of a problem to begin with, and 2) when they know about it but lack the will to act upon it, or act upon it to the extent that sufficient change materialises. Let’s see what examples we can choose for each case.
To begin, the collective pursuit of self-interest directs authorities to the existence or severity of a societal problem where they lack the political acumen to do so.
Example: #MeToo (2017 - 2024): An actress’ tweet in the wake of Weinstein’s sexual assault revelations quickly cascaded into a movement sweeping across virtually all developed countries — jolting authorities worldwide who had failed to grasp the true scale of sexual abuse, which millions of testimonies finally illuminated.
Crucially, its composition — women determined to rally against such injustices after the terrible violations of self-interest they had endured — led to the rectification of many legal blind spots that lawmakers had not treated as problems, such as non-disclosure agreements and forced arbitration clauses that kept sexual abuse cases hidden from the public eye.
While the self-interest of one may be waved aside as simple egotism, the convergence of many upon the same self-interest hints at the existence of deeper, systemic flaws — often placing them under a national spotlight which then establishes the backdrop for robust civil discourse. Simultaneously, mass support endows greater visibility and prominence to the movement itself, mounting pressure on authorities and, in turn, giving rise to the necessary momentum to translate that discourse into concrete legislative or executive reform.
In fact, when sufficient people join forces due to shared grievances, the resulting effects arguably almost indistinguishable from altruism; for any structural change that results from this collective pursuit immediately benefits others who had previously been robbed of that same self-interest — which, given the universality of said grievances, almost always aligns with the greater good — regardless of whether they had undertaken that pursuit themselves.
A good tip is to start from the most well-known, international movements, and run through them one by one to see which one could work — before moving on to more regional or national examples.
Feel free to also talk about more peaceful routes to change such as petitions, feedback through official channels, media, etc, which are also ways that governments can realise the existence of a problem.
Crucially, should authorities instead lack the will to tackle societal ills, this pursuit of self-interest retains the coercive force to push through political inertia and manifest concrete change.
Here we have a buffet of well-known examples to choose from. The Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement, for instance, did not surface anything the US government was not already cognisant of — despite systemic discrimination and abusive policing being well-documented issues which transcended partisan lines, the fear of appearing “soft on crime” and constitutional barriers such as officer immunity from personal liability* cemented a broader political inaction as the norm. Yet the sheer scale and vehemence of the protests, unprecedented in state history, shifted the political calculus with such celerity that, within a year, police reforms officially entered legislation across more than 30 states.
You can also consider China’s White Paper Protests (2022). What was originally a protest against invasive and draconian “Zero-Covid” measures quickly escalated into a nationwide rebellion — punctuated with pieces of blank paper held up in triumph — against excessive state censorship. The fact that authorities were compelled into abruptly rescinding the containment measures is all the more remarkable given the country’s reputation for accommodating no dissent. This is testament to the sheer gravity of self-interest when embodied by an entire population, even against a state whose authority appears unassailable.
Any well-known, international example works just fine here — just remember to explain and elaborate on your example using keywords that closely link to the question, like what we’ve been doing for each example so far.
Where executive or legislative barriers would otherwise inhibit change on a systemic level, acting in accordance with self-interest is arguably the sole way for the people to magnify individual voices while heightening the stakes for those in power, so as to ultimately push through these same barriers.
*On personal liability: they cannot be personally sued unless the plaintiff proves that the officer had violated a “clearly established“ constitutional right, which is almost never the case in racially motivated policing
(Optional) At the very least, protests as an expression of self-interest act as a form of pressure-valve or outlet for its initiators, who derive subjective value from the very act of participating.
SG Population White Paper protests (2013): In one of the largest national protests since independence, thousands gathered at Hong Lim Park after the 6.9 million population projection quickly became a lightning rod for public discontent. Their concerns were self-interested: suppressed wages, surging housing prices and overcrowding due to the influx of foreign immigrants*. Ultimately, the rally at Speakers’ Corner allowed public anger to be aired peacefully, while the government was prompted to pass an amended notion with tightened foreigner inflows.
*Notice how throughout the essay, examples are embedded with explanations and elaborations that link to the “self-interest” keyword, whether explicitly or not.
The reason why this third angle is optional: it’s difficult to come up with an example in the exam that does not undermine your topic sentence, because an examiner may argue that venting actually defuses the pressure for structural change (you protest, feel better, and go home). You could still argue that pursuing self-interest is good because it does make you feel better — but this is still weaker than our other angles because that ”good” is still largely an illusion if nothing concrete actually changes after the protest. The 2013 case helps us here, since the protest both helped to diffuse anger and shift policy, which allows us to present the valve as the minimum protests achieve.
Seen from another angle, protests and movements are an externalisation of citizens’ resolve to wrest back control from a world governed by broad, inscrutable (impossible to understand) forces and which seems to be spiralling out of theirs. In an increasingly unpredictable climate (entrenched inequalities, social tensions/fragmentation, even the stressors of everyday life), that sense of helplessness is often amplified.
As such, pursuing self-interest becomes a form of recourse to justice, or at the very least a form of catharsis, that is more necessary than ever.
Notice how there are two distinct cases we are addressing here: 1) when authorities are not aware of the seriousness of a problem to begin with, and 2) when they know about it but lack the will to act upon it, or act upon it to the extent that sufficient change materialises. Let’s see what examples we can choose for each case.
To begin, the collective pursuit of self-interest directs authorities to the existence or severity of a societal problem where they lack the political acumen to do so.
Example: #MeToo (2017 - 2024): An actress’ tweet in the wake of Weinstein’s sexual assault revelations quickly cascaded into a movement sweeping across virtually all developed countries — jolting authorities worldwide who had failed to grasp the true scale of sexual abuse, which millions of testimonies finally illuminated.
Crucially, its composition — women determined to rally against such injustices after the terrible violations of self-interest they had endured — led to the rectification of many legal blind spots that lawmakers had not treated as problems, such as non-disclosure agreements and forced arbitration clauses that kept sexual abuse cases hidden from the public eye.
While the self-interest of one may be waved aside as simple egotism, the convergence of many upon the same self-interest hints at the existence of deeper, systemic flaws — often placing them under a national spotlight which then establishes the backdrop for robust civil discourse. Simultaneously, mass support endows greater visibility and prominence to the movement itself, mounting pressure on authorities and, in turn, giving rise to the necessary momentum to translate that discourse into concrete legislative or executive reform.
In fact, when sufficient people join forces due to shared grievances, the resulting effects arguably almost indistinguishable from altruism; for any structural change that results from this collective pursuit immediately benefits others who had previously been robbed of that same self-interest — which, given the universality of said grievances, almost always aligns with the greater good — regardless of whether they had undertaken that pursuit themselves.
A good tip is to start from the most well-known, international movements, and run through them one by one to see which one could work — before moving on to more regional or national examples.
Feel free to also talk about more peaceful routes to change such as petitions, feedback through official channels, media, etc, which are also ways that governments can realise the existence of a problem.
Crucially, should authorities instead lack the will to tackle societal ills, this pursuit of self-interest retains the coercive force to push through political inertia and manifest concrete change.
Here we have a buffet of well-known examples to choose from. The Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement, for instance, did not surface anything the US government was not already cognisant of — despite systemic discrimination and abusive policing being well-documented issues which transcended partisan lines, the fear of appearing “soft on crime” and constitutional barriers such as officer immunity from personal liability* cemented a broader political inaction as the norm. Yet the sheer scale and vehemence of the protests, unprecedented in state history, shifted the political calculus with such celerity that, within a year, police reforms officially entered legislation across more than 30 states.
You can also consider China’s White Paper Protests (2022). What was originally a protest against invasive and draconian “Zero-Covid” measures quickly escalated into a nationwide rebellion — punctuated with pieces of blank paper held up in triumph — against excessive state censorship. The fact that authorities were compelled into abruptly rescinding the containment measures is all the more remarkable given the country’s reputation for accommodating no dissent. This is testament to the sheer gravity of self-interest when embodied by an entire population, even against a state whose authority appears unassailable.
Any well-known, international example works just fine here — just remember to explain and elaborate on your example using keywords that closely link to the question, like what we’ve been doing for each example so far.
Where executive or legislative barriers would otherwise inhibit change on a systemic level, acting in accordance with self-interest is arguably the sole way for the people to magnify individual voices while heightening the stakes for those in power, so as to ultimately push through these same barriers.
*On personal liability: they cannot be personally sued unless the plaintiff proves that the officer had violated a “clearly established“ constitutional right, which is almost never the case in racially motivated policing
(Optional) At the very least, protests as an expression of self-interest act as a form of pressure-valve or outlet for its initiators, who derive subjective value from the very act of participating.
SG Population White Paper protests (2013): In one of the largest national protests since independence, thousands gathered at Hong Lim Park after the 6.9 million population projection quickly became a lightning rod for public discontent. Their concerns were self-interested: suppressed wages, surging housing prices and overcrowding due to the influx of foreign immigrants*. Ultimately, the rally at Speakers’ Corner allowed public anger to be aired peacefully, while the government was prompted to pass an amended notion with tightened foreigner inflows.
*Notice how throughout the essay, examples are embedded with explanations and elaborations that link to the “self-interest” keyword, whether explicitly or not.
The reason why this third angle is optional: it’s difficult to come up with an example in the exam that does not undermine your topic sentence, because an examiner may argue that venting actually defuses the pressure for structural change (you protest, feel better, and go home). You could still argue that pursuing self-interest is good because it does make you feel better — but this is still weaker than our other angles because that ”good” is still largely an illusion if nothing concrete actually changes after the protest. The 2013 case helps us here, since the protest both helped to diffuse anger and shift policy, which allows us to present the valve as the minimum protests achieve.
Seen from another angle, protests and movements are an externalisation of citizens’ resolve to wrest back control from a world governed by broad, inscrutable (impossible to understand) forces and which seems to be spiralling out of theirs. In an increasingly unpredictable climate (entrenched inequalities, social tensions/fragmentation, even the stressors of everyday life), that sense of helplessness is often amplified.
As such, pursuing self-interest becomes a form of recourse to justice, or at the very least a form of catharsis, that is more necessary than ever.
(Additional Reading) Antithesis 4
(Additional Reading) Antithesis 4
(Additional Reading) Antithesis 4
Good job working through all the previous mental exercises! We believe there's one more potential antithesis you can come up with, so just sit back and read through this one.
Thought process
Here, we can actually use a variation of the 3rd For argument: that what is "self-interest" may be unclear, misleading or even illusive — for whatever reason. In that case, we have:
Good job working through all the previous mental exercises! We believe there's one more potential antithesis you can come up with, so just sit back and read through this one.
Thought process
Here, we can actually use a variation of the 3rd For argument: that what is "self-interest" may be unclear, misleading or even illusive — for whatever reason. In that case, we have:
Good job working through all the previous mental exercises! We believe there's one more potential antithesis you can come up with, so just sit back and read through this one.
Thought process
Here, we can actually use a variation of the 3rd For argument: that what is "self-interest" may be unclear, misleading or even illusive — for whatever reason. In that case, we have:
Topic Sentence
The pursuit of self-interest can be misguided and illusive, yet cannot be deemed bad because that reality is obscured during the initial pursuit — a fact that is only exacerbated by the world’s increasing volatility.
Topic Sentence
The pursuit of self-interest can be misguided and illusive, yet cannot be deemed bad because that reality is obscured during the initial pursuit — a fact that is only exacerbated by the world’s increasing volatility.
Framework: Appearance vs. Reality
Apparent self-interest may be different from actual self-interest, and that is sometimes not our fault.
Framework: Appearance vs. Reality
Apparent self-interest may be different from actual self-interest, and that is sometimes not our fault.
Framework: Appearance vs. Reality
Apparent self-interest may be different from actual self-interest, and that is sometimes not our fault.
At times, this can be the result of deliberate interference or manipulation, by figures in power seeking to sway the tide of public opinion to align with self-serving political agendas.
Let’s revisit Brexit again: as we established, majority of citizens regretted their decision in retrospect. Yet in the period leading up to the referendum, many were already growing increasingly hostile towards immigrants and disillusioned by Britain’s economic performance under the EU. That arguably made them more susceptible to political control as the Leave bloc capitalised on this emotional volatility by inciting greater contempt for EU membership: via populist rhetoric alongside passionate appeals to nationalism. That created an widespread illusion of agency of moving in the direction of the collective self-interest, which made Brexit feel like a natural decision long overdue when it wasn’t.
You can also discuss how modern technology worsens this uncertainty in decision-making, given the rise of misinformation and the channels through which misleading information, like in the case of Brexit, can be disseminated by those seeking political gain in a way that largely evades public awareness.
At others, this opacity is a result of a structural lack of information to accurately forecast the true utility of an enacted policy or measure. That could result in unintended consequences, invisible at the time of conception, which unfortunately end up causing more harm than good.
In the 2010s, former German chancellor Angela Merkel’s “open-door” policy enabled thousands of Syrian refugees seeking asylum to enter the country. Yet she failed to consider the integrity of the social fabric upon assimilating so many migrants from distinct cultural backgrounds. That led to housing shortages and a sharp rise in crime and social conflict, with tensions eventually culminating in violent riots in 2018 (the Chemnitz riots).
Or you could talk about China’s one-child policy, where it sought to secure prosperity by suppressing population growth. Yet the measure changed household norms so effectively that ten years on, it has found itself in an unprecedented ageing crisis because families no longer desired children amidst rising costs of living and the educational arms race.
Thus, what appears to be a path towards outcomes which are beneficial to the people or in accordance with the nation’s objectives may ironically diverge from them or even prove counterproductive to achieving these very goals, as a result of unforeseen complications.
Linking back to the context, this problem of imperfect information is compounded by an increasingly volatile environment — whether it’s the geopolitical instability which led to the Syrian migrant crisis in the first place, or the rapid modernisation of China which led to drastic shifts in the national culture. As such, we cannot assign a negative value judgement to such pursuits because at the moment of judgement, the decision appears to bring about net positive outcomes.
At times, this can be the result of deliberate interference or manipulation, by figures in power seeking to sway the tide of public opinion to align with self-serving political agendas.
Let’s revisit Brexit again: as we established, majority of citizens regretted their decision in retrospect. Yet in the period leading up to the referendum, many were already growing increasingly hostile towards immigrants and disillusioned by Britain’s economic performance under the EU. That arguably made them more susceptible to political control as the Leave bloc capitalised on this emotional volatility by inciting greater contempt for EU membership: via populist rhetoric alongside passionate appeals to nationalism. That created an widespread illusion of agency of moving in the direction of the collective self-interest, which made Brexit feel like a natural decision long overdue when it wasn’t.
You can also discuss how modern technology worsens this uncertainty in decision-making, given the rise of misinformation and the channels through which misleading information, like in the case of Brexit, can be disseminated by those seeking political gain in a way that largely evades public awareness.
At others, this opacity is a result of a structural lack of information to accurately forecast the true utility of an enacted policy or measure. That could result in unintended consequences, invisible at the time of conception, which unfortunately end up causing more harm than good.
In the 2010s, former German chancellor Angela Merkel’s “open-door” policy enabled thousands of Syrian refugees seeking asylum to enter the country. Yet she failed to consider the integrity of the social fabric upon assimilating so many migrants from distinct cultural backgrounds. That led to housing shortages and a sharp rise in crime and social conflict, with tensions eventually culminating in violent riots in 2018 (the Chemnitz riots).
Or you could talk about China’s one-child policy, where it sought to secure prosperity by suppressing population growth. Yet the measure changed household norms so effectively that ten years on, it has found itself in an unprecedented ageing crisis because families no longer desired children amidst rising costs of living and the educational arms race.
Thus, what appears to be a path towards outcomes which are beneficial to the people or in accordance with the nation’s objectives may ironically diverge from them or even prove counterproductive to achieving these very goals, as a result of unforeseen complications.
Linking back to the context, this problem of imperfect information is compounded by an increasingly volatile environment — whether it’s the geopolitical instability which led to the Syrian migrant crisis in the first place, or the rapid modernisation of China which led to drastic shifts in the national culture. As such, we cannot assign a negative value judgement to such pursuits because at the moment of judgement, the decision appears to bring about net positive outcomes.
In A Nutshell
In A Nutshell
In A Nutshell
That concludes our discussion on this essay question! Again, quite a lot of content, but there's no need at all to use everything — take away what aligns with you! Finally, a quick summary of the key recurring insights throughout this essay:
Pursuing self-interest itself is not inherently bad and in fact what every country should strive for, since it’s natural and important to ensure your own wellbeing. Yet the way you pursue it, paradoxically, is not by directly focusing on self-interest but often through collaborative efforts.
For the people, pursuing self-interest isn’t necessarily bad either, especially with many people coming together because they coincidentally have the same demands to make — since that is then a sign of a greater societal problem.
Pursuing self-interest and benefitting others are not opposites; in fact, they can coexist as natural results of one another.
That's it for today — see you in the next piece :)
That concludes our discussion on this essay question! Again, quite a lot of content, but there's no need at all to use everything — take away what aligns with you! Finally, a quick summary of the key recurring insights throughout this essay:
Pursuing self-interest itself is not inherently bad and in fact what every country should strive for, since it’s natural and important to ensure your own wellbeing. Yet the way you pursue it, paradoxically, is not by directly focusing on self-interest but often through collaborative efforts.
For the people, pursuing self-interest isn’t necessarily bad either, especially with many people coming together because they coincidentally have the same demands to make — since that is then a sign of a greater societal problem.
Pursuing self-interest and benefitting others are not opposites; in fact, they can coexist as natural results of one another.
That's it for today — see you in the next piece :)
That concludes our discussion on this essay question! Again, quite a lot of content, but there's no need at all to use everything — take away what aligns with you! Finally, a quick summary of the key recurring insights throughout this essay:
Pursuing self-interest itself is not inherently bad and in fact what every country should strive for, since it’s natural and important to ensure your own wellbeing. Yet the way you pursue it, paradoxically, is not by directly focusing on self-interest but often through collaborative efforts.
For the people, pursuing self-interest isn’t necessarily bad either, especially with many people coming together because they coincidentally have the same demands to make — since that is then a sign of a greater societal problem.
Pursuing self-interest and benefitting others are not opposites; in fact, they can coexist as natural results of one another.
That's it for today — see you in the next piece :)



