Essay 3
Essay 3
Essay 3
Is there any point in believing the unverifiable?
Is there any point in believing the unverifiable?
Is there any point in believing the unverifiable?
And no, it's not just religion
And no, it's not just religion

The idea that the only good argumentative structure is a PEEL structure is outdated.
Same goes for PEEEL, TEAL or whatever acronym someone told you to follow.
The reality is, examples, explanations, elaborations and evaluations were never fixed in sequence — they can be, and are often, intertwined with each other. Frameworks such as PEEL are certainly useful when you're just starting out or beginning your GP journey, but never let that limit you; it is not necessary to follow that structure. That said, there are a few general rules around how to organise each body paragraph:
You should open with a topic sentence/thesis (Point) or at most a brief leadup before you introduce the main point.
Ideally, a good closing sentence (Link) should either link back to your topic sentence, the essay question itself, or consolidataing what's at stake in that paragraph. It typically summarises a personal judgement or key insight(s) directly related to the original question.
After each Example should be some kind of Evaluation — sensemaking of the example. What inferences can you make? What insight, observation, trends etc can we draw from this example to show the examiner? What are therefore, the implications or consequences on society, or whatever stakeholders relevant to the question?
Your Evaluation should occupy at least as many lines on the foolscap as your Example, as much as possible! It's easy to recite facts and current affairs, but what the reader really wants to know is: so what?
There is really no fixed place which your "Explanation" and "Elaboration" should go. Just remember that they are used to substantiate and supplement your Evaluation — which answers the "so what?" — by filling in the "why?" and "how", as well as help you bring in additional layers of argument ("sub-points"). More details below.
We know this all sounds very woozy and abstract right now, but as we close read more newsletters and essays, you will quickly get better at designing and writing body paragraphs. You can think of the Newsletter as your ammunition store, to provide you with content for your Points and Evaluations (+ supporting Explanations, Elaborations); the Essays will be where we see all that in action, where all the components come together.
Let's start by looking at the introductory essay below! Before we begin dissecting the essay, let us introduce the key components of any argumentative piece. You might have come across similar components under different names; just stick with the names you’re familiar with.
The idea that the only good argumentative structure is a PEEL structure is outdated.
Same goes for PEEEL, TEAL or whatever acronym someone told you to follow.
The reality is, examples, explanations, elaborations and evaluations were never fixed in sequence — they can be, and are often, intertwined with each other. Frameworks such as PEEL are certainly useful when you're just starting out or beginning your GP journey, but never let that limit you; it is not necessary to follow that structure. That said, there are a few general rules around how to organise each body paragraph:
You should open with a topic sentence/thesis (Point) or at most a brief leadup before you introduce the main point.
Ideally, a good closing sentence (Link) should either link back to your topic sentence, the essay question itself, or consolidataing what's at stake in that paragraph. It typically summarises a personal judgement or key insight(s) directly related to the original question.
After each Example should be some kind of Evaluation — sensemaking of the example. What inferences can you make? What insight, observation, trends etc can we draw from this example to show the examiner? What are therefore, the implications or consequences on society, or whatever stakeholders relevant to the question?
Your Evaluation should occupy at least as many lines on the foolscap as your Example, as much as possible! It's easy to recite facts and current affairs, but what the reader really wants to know is: so what?
There is really no fixed place which your "Explanation" and "Elaboration" should go. Just remember that they are used to substantiate and supplement your Evaluation — which answers the "so what?" — by filling in the "why?" and "how", as well as help you bring in additional layers of argument ("sub-points"). More details below.
We know this all sounds very woozy and abstract right now, but as we close read more newsletters and essays, you will quickly get better at designing and writing body paragraphs. You can think of the Newsletter as your ammunition store, to provide you with content for your Points and Evaluations (+ supporting Explanations, Elaborations); the Essays will be where we see all that in action, where all the components come together.
Let's start by looking at the introductory essay below! Before we begin dissecting the essay, let us introduce the key components of any argumentative piece. You might have come across similar components under different names; just stick with the names you’re familiar with.
Components of a GP Essay
Highlighter color codes on the left
Components of a GP Essay
Highlighter color codes on the left
Hook
The opening of an essay which should immediately capture the reader’s attention, so as to convince them to read on. (Remember, examiners are hardly patient when they have to mark hundreds of scripts).
Hook
The opening of an essay which should immediately capture the reader’s attention, so as to convince them to read on. (Remember, examiners are hardly patient when they have to mark hundreds of scripts).
Main Thesis
A declaration of your overall stance and the core idea(s) you’ll be discussing throughout your essay, including a possible caveat or counter-argument which is addressed later on. You do not need to be too detailed.
Main Thesis
A declaration of your overall stance and the core idea(s) you’ll be discussing throughout your essay, including a possible caveat or counter-argument which is addressed later on. You do not need to be too detailed.
Thesis / Topic Sentence
The main point you are trying to bring forth in a body paragraph; the entire argument captured in 1 or 2 sentences. A standard GP essay should include 4 topic sentences — 1 for a counterargument (antithesis in red), 3 for supporting arguments, of which 1 is often a rebuttal paragraph.
Thesis / Topic Sentence
The main point you are trying to bring forth in a body paragraph; the entire argument captured in 1 or 2 sentences. A standard GP essay should include 4 topic sentences — 1 for a counterargument (antithesis in red), 3 for supporting arguments, of which 1 is often a rebuttal paragraph.
Example
Factual evidence which supports your argument. However, the Example should not simply be a regurgitation of facts; phrases and keywords that explicitly link back to your thesis are necessary. For that reason, it is often intertwined with Elaboration and Explanation, as we shall see below.
Example
Factual evidence which supports your argument. However, the Example should not simply be a regurgitation of facts; phrases and keywords that explicitly link back to your thesis are necessary. For that reason, it is often intertwined with Elaboration and Explanation, as we shall see below.
Explanation
Provides the justification and reasoning in support of the claim you’re currently making — answers the "why": “why is this so?” “what makes this convincing/true?” Typically does not come with signposts like "this is because", to avoid sounding robotic.
Explanation
Provides the justification and reasoning in support of the claim you’re currently making — answers the "why": “why is this so?” “what makes this convincing/true?” Typically does not come with signposts like "this is because", to avoid sounding robotic.
Elaboration
This develops the argument by pushing it to greater depth (causes, mechanisms), or greater breadth (impacts, implications). Here are some signposts which you’ve probably seen: Moreover… / Worse… / Amplifying this is… / In fact… / Furthermore…
Elaboration
This develops the argument by pushing it to greater depth (causes, mechanisms), or greater breadth (impacts, implications). Here are some signposts which you’ve probably seen: Moreover… / Worse… / Amplifying this is… / In fact… / Furthermore…
Evaluation
Perhaps the most important part of the essay. Presenting insights — observations, claims, tendencies, patterns etc — arrived at after Analysis.
Demonstrates your personal judgement on the issue at hand or the idea being discussed.
Discusses the wider implications of your argument — what is at stake? who is affected? what are the consequences to society or the world?
Evaluation
Perhaps the most important part of the essay. Presenting insights — observations, claims, tendencies, patterns etc — arrived at after Analysis.
Demonstrates your personal judgement on the issue at hand or the idea being discussed.
Discusses the wider implications of your argument — what is at stake? who is affected? what are the consequences to society or the world?
Link
Also a type of Evaluative statement that usually connects back to and reinforces your topic sentence.
Link
Also a type of Evaluative statement that usually connects back to and reinforces your topic sentence.
Conclusion
A summary of the main arguments you’ve covered in the essay, alongside a thought-provoking ending to the essay. There are many different ways and techniques to end an essay powerfully and distinctively — we will cover some of these in the Starter Kit.
Conclusion
A summary of the main arguments you’ve covered in the essay, alongside a thought-provoking ending to the essay. There are many different ways and techniques to end an essay powerfully and distinctively — we will cover some of these in the Starter Kit.
Introductory Essay
Following colour codes above
Introductory Essay
Following colour codes above
View Author's Commentary
View Author's Commentary
View Author's Commentary
View Author's Commentary
View Author's Commentary
View Author's Commentary
View Author's Commentary



